This dissertation explores the racial, gendered, and industrial politics of televised sports punditry, charting the genre’s movement from newspaper columns and talk radio programs onto the airwaves of cable television in the late 1990s and early 2000s. The project addresses the question of how popular sports punditry programs on cable television differ from contemporary political punditry programs in their treatment of racial and gender issues. I interpret the rise and sustained popularity of these programs as reflections of various social and political currents, ranging from postracialism and neoliberalism to the more overt racism and sexism of the Tea Party and, later, Trumpism. By critically reading popular pundit programs across major channels like ESPN and Fox Sports 1 (FS1), I link programs like Pardon the Interruption, First Take, Speak for Yourself, and Garbage Time with Katie Nolan into a broader conversation about racial and gender identity on cable television. I argue that while sports punditry programs on cable feature a greater diversity of racial representation than their political counterparts, this diversity often occurred at the expense of exploring issues of systemic racism in sports and sports media. Additionally, I argue that these programs achieved popularity by trading on both contemporary and historical racial tensions and stereotypes of racialized masculinity to appeal to viewers. I argue that these programs reinforce sport as a postracial utopia while largely denying ongoing systemic racism and sexism in sports, upholding sports as an apolitical meritocracy. While other literature on sport media conducts content analyses of sports news programs and game broadcasts, my dissertation extends this work to punditry programs, studying not just their place in the cable television and sport media industries, but also the racial and gender politics of these programs and their star pundits.