This paper studies when the priority composition of corporate debt affects recovery outcomes beyond the allocation of default proceeds under strict priority. We develop a structural model with senior and junior debt, fair pricing at initial issuance, scheduled rollover, and endogenous default. The model delivers a neutrality benchmark: when the two classes share the same maturity, tax treatment, and refinancing technology, changing the junior share reallocates a given recovery pool but leaves aggregate debt service, equity value, the default boundary, and the recovery pool unchanged. Class-specific refinancing costs or rollover frequencies break this neutrality by changing the refinancing losses borne by equity. Quantitatively, the allocation channel accounts for most of the change in class-level recovery rates; the refinancing channel is smaller and increases with the refinancing-cost wedge and rollover frequency. Using market-based recoveries on defaulted corporate bonds, we find robust within-default-event differences across priority classes. Event-level public-bond recovery indices are also more strongly related to lower-priority bond share when near-term public-bond refinancing exposure is high, although this evidence is based on limited joint support and is interpreted as descriptive. The results identify the conditions under which priority operates only as an ex post allocation rule and those under which priority-linked refinancing exposure also affects default and recovery before recovery value is allocated across creditor classes.