Menimbang Prospek Komunikasi Individual HAM: Politik Hukum dan Implikasi Potensial Bagi Indonesia
Authors:
- Abdul Munif AshriAAAbdul Munif Ashri
- Heribertus Jaka TriyanaHTHeribertus Jaka Triyana
Open Access
- 18 December 2024
- journal article
- Published by Badan Strategi Kebijakan Hukum, Kementerian Hukum Republik Indonesia in Jurnal HAM
- Vol. 15 (3)
Abstract
The individual communications procedure is a vital mechanism in international human rights law that enables victims to seek remedies when domestic legal venues have been exhausted or failed to deliver justice. Although Indonesia has acceded to almost all core international human rights treaties, its individual communications procedures have yet to be accepted. This study investigates the Indonesian Government’s human rights legal policy toward individual communications procedures acceptance through the ratification/accession of the ICCPR First Optional Protocol and ICESCR Optional Protocol, as well as analyzes the potential implications of such acceptance. This study utilizes a normative legal methodology coupled with interdisciplinary and conceptual approaches. In addition to analyzing legal materials, interviews were conducted with scholars, NGO activist, victim, and former Commissioner of Indonesia’s National Human Rights Commission to deepen the analysis. The findings reveal the Government’s lack of political will to accept individual communications procedures due to a tendency to avoid adjudicatory human rights accountability mechanisms and the avoidance of possible compliance costs, such as financial, reputational, and political burdens. Furthermore, this study demonstrates that these procedures’ acceptance has potential implications for opening access to justice for victims, providing strategic litigation channels, and facilitating interaction between treaty bodies and the national judiciary regarding the development of interpretations of human rights through judicial dialogue. The Government should consider ratifying/acceding the ICCPR and ICESCR Optional Protocols to strengthen the domestic human rights protection infrastructure and enhance its reputation as a promoter of human rights.Keywords
This publication has 50 references indexed in Scilit:
- Protection of Human Rights in East and Southeast Asian Countries After World War II: A Short Comment on the Keynote Speech of Vice-President Judge Nußberger2023
- Human rights courts and global constitutionalism: Coordination through judicial dialogueGlobal Constitutionalism, 2020
- The Human Rights Courts2019
- María de los Ángeles González Carreño v. Ministry of JusticeAmerican Journal of International Law, 2019
- The ASEAN Human Rights System: A Critical AnalysisAsian Journal of Comparative Law, 2016
- Domestic Politics and International Human Rights Tribunals2013
- The Persistent Power of Human Rights2013
- Individual complaints2012
- The socialization of international human rights norms into domestic practices: introduction1999
- Linking the unlinkable? International norms and nationalism in Indonesia and the Philippines1999