3.0-T Evaluation of Knee Cartilage by Using Three-Dimensional IDEAL GRASS Imaging: Comparison with Fast Spin-Echo Imaging
Authors:
- Richard KijowskiRKRichard Kijowski
- Donna G. BlankenbakerDBDonna G. Blankenbaker
- Michael A. WoodsMWMichael A. Woods
- Kazuhiko ShinkiKSKazuhiko Shinki
- Arthur A. De SmetASArthur A. De Smet
- Scott B. ReederSRScott B. Reeder
- 1 April 2010
- journal article
- Published by Radiological Society of North America (RSNA) in Radiology
- Vol. 255 (1) , 117-127
Abstract
To compare the diagnostic performance of iterative decomposition of water and fat with echo asymmetry and least-squares estimation (IDEAL) gradient-recalled acquisition in steady-state (GRASS) imaging with a routine magnetic resonance (MR) imaging protocol for evaluating knee cartilage at 3.0 T in patients by using arthroscopy as the reference standard. This prospective Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act-compliant study was performed with a waiver of informed consent from the institutional review board. IDEAL GRASS was added to routine 3.0-T knee MR protocol performed in 95 symptomatic patients (48 males, mean age, 34.5 years; 47 females, mean age, 35.5 years) who underwent subsequent arthroscopic surgery. Radiologists used the routine MR protocol during the first review and IDEAL GRASS during the second to grade each articular surface and to determine the presence of meniscal tears. By using arthroscopy as the reference standard, the sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of both imaging methods for detecting cartilage lesions and meniscal tears were determined. By using the z test to compare parameters between methods, the respective sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy for detecting all 192 cartilage lesions were 68.5%, 92.6%, and 84.5% for IDEAL GRASS and 66.1%, 92.9%, and 83.9% for the routine MR protocol. There was no significant difference (P = .34-.83) in parameters between methods for detecting cartilage lesions. The respective parameters for detecting 50 medial meniscal tears were 85.0%, 91.1%, and 87.9% for IDEAL GRASS and 94.0%, 90.0%, and 92.1% for the routine MR protocol. The parameters for detecting 31 lateral meniscal tears were 58.0%, 90.6%, and 80.0% for IDEAL GRASS and 80.1%, 91.4%, and 87.9% for the routine MR protocol. The routine MR protocol had a significantly higher sensitivity for detecting medial meniscal tears (P = .04) and lateral meniscal tears (P = .01) and significantly higher accuracy for detecting lateral meniscal tears (P = .03) than IDEAL GRASS. IDEAL GRASS has similar diagnostic performance as routine MR protocol for evaluating the articular cartilage of the knee in clinical patients at 3.0 T but has significantly lower sensitivity and accuracy for detecting meniscal tears.Keywords
This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit:
- Multiecho IDEAL Gradient-Echo Water-Fat Separation for Rapid Assessment of Cartilage Volume at 1.5 T: Initial ExperienceRadiology, 2009
- Improved fat suppression using multipeak reconstruction for IDEAL chemical shift fat‐water separation: Application with fast spin echo imagingJournal of Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 2009
- Multiecho water‐fat separation and simultaneous R estimation with multifrequency fat spectrum modelingMagnetic Resonance in Medicine, 2008
- Cartilage imaging at 3.0T with gradient refocused acquisition in the steady-state (GRASS) and IDEAL fat-water separationJournal of Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 2008
- Water–fat separation with IDEAL gradient‐echo imagingJournal of Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 2007
- Homodyne reconstruction and IDEAL water–fat decompositionMagnetic Resonance in Medicine, 2005
- Bone Marrow Edema and Its Relation to Progression of Knee OsteoarthritisAnnals of Internal Medicine, 2003
- Symptomatic Articular Cartilage DegenerationClinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, 2001
- Magnetic resonance imaging of superficial cartilage lesions: Role of contrast in lesion detectionJournal of Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 1999
- Chondromalacia patellae.American Journal of Roentgenology, 1992