Pragmatic Rigor: Principles and Criteria for Conducting and Evaluating Practitioner Scholarship
Open Access
- 27 December 2018
- journal article
- Published by Case Western Reserve University in Engaged Management ReView
- Vol. 2 (3) , 2
Abstract
Practitioner scholarship is a promising avenue for addressing the gap between academic research and practice. To advance the objective of publishing the findings of practitioner scholarship, we develop the concept of pragmatic rigor, which is intended to complement but not replace scientific rigor. We propose four principles of pragmatic rigor: relevance, actionability, comprehensibility, and ethical reasoning. For each principle, we develop associated criteria for conducting and evaluating practical research. Pragmatic principles are relevant to the research process, from choice of topic to final evaluation by journal reviewers. We believe that applying these principles can advance the practical value of studies and help to bridge the gap between scholars and practitioners.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Revisiting IS research practice in the era of big dataInformation and Organization, 2019
- Strategic signalling and awards: Investigation into the first decade of AIS best publications awardsThe Journal of Strategic Information Systems, 2017
- Toward a theory of collaboration for evidence-based managementManagement Decision, 2016
- Measuring the actionability of evidence for evidence-based managementManagement Decision, 2016
- The source and status of values for socially responsible sciencePhilosophical Studies, 2012
- DECONSTRUCTING COMPREHENSIBILITYStudies in Second Language Acquisition, 2012
- Bridging social and technical interfaces in organizations: An interpretive analysis of time-space distanciationInformation and Organization, 2008
- You're an organization development practitioner-scholar: Can you contribute to organizational theory?Organization Management Journal, 2008
- Principles of canonical action researchInformation Systems Journal, 2004
- A disciplined methodological pluralism for mis researchAccounting, Management and Information Technologies, 1992