Robustness of potential biological removal to monitoring, environmental, and management uncertainties
Authors:
- André E PuntAPAndré E Punt
- Margaret SipleMSMargaret Siple
- Tessa B FrancisTFTessa B Francis
- Phillip S HammondPHPhillip S Hammond
- Kristy J LongKLKristy J Long
- Jeffrey E MooreJMJeffrey E Moore
- Maritza SepúlvedaMSMaritza Sepúlveda
- Guðjón Már SigurðssonGSGuðjón Már Sigurðsson
- Gísli VikingssonGVGísli Vikingsson
- Paul R WadePWPaul R Wade
Open Access
- 10 September 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in ICES Journal of Marine Science
- Vol. 77 (7-8) , 2491-2507
Abstract
The potential biological removal (PBR) formula used to determine a reference point for human-caused mortality of marine mammals in the United States has been shown to be robust to several sources of uncertainty. This study investigates the consequences of the quality of monitoring on PBR performance. It also explores stochastic and demographic uncertainty, catastrophic events, sublethal effects of interactions with fishing gear, and the situation of a marine mammal population subject to bycatch in two fisheries, only one of which is managed. Results are presented for two pinniped and two cetacean life histories. Bias in abundance estimates and whether there is a linear relationship between abundance estimates and true abundance most influence conservation performance. Catastrophic events and trends in natural mortality have larger effects than environmental stochasticity. Managing only one of two fisheries with significant bycatch leads, as expected, to a lower probability of achieving conservation management goals, and better outcomes would be achieved if bycatch in all fisheries were managed. The results are qualitatively the same for the four life histories, but estimates of the probability of population recovery differ.Keywords
Funding Information
- Pew Charitable Trusts
- Lenfest Ocean Program
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Management strategy evaluation: a powerful tool for conservation?Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 2011
- Spectra® fishing twine entanglement of a bottlenose dolphin: A case study and experimental modelingMarine Pollution Bulletin, 2010
- Consequences of injuries on survival and reproduction of common bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) along the west coast of FloridaMarine Mammal Science, 2008
- Developing management procedures that are robust to uncertainty: lessons from the International Whaling CommissionICES Journal of Marine Science, 2007
- A new abundance estimate for Maui’s dolphin: What does it mean for managing this critically endangered species?Biological Conservation, 2006
- Distribution, abundance and conservation status of dugongs and dolphins in the southern and western Arabian GulfBiological Conservation, 2004
- A MODEL LIFE TABLE FOR BOTTLENOSE DOLPHINS (TURSIOPS TRUNCATUS) FROM THE INDIAN RIVER LAGOON SYSTEM, FLORIDA, U.S.A.Marine Mammal Science, 2003
- Potential limits to anthropogenic mortality for harbour porpoises in the Baltic regionBiological Conservation, 2002
- COMPARATIVE POPULATION DYNAMICS OF FUR SEALSMarine Mammal Science, 1997
- DIE‐OFFS OF MARINE MAMMALS AND SEA BIRDS IN THE GULF OF CALIFORNIA, MÉXICOMarine Mammal Science, 1996