Investigating the Effects of Threatening Language, Message Framing, and Reactance in Opt-Out Organ Donation Campaigns
Authors:
Open Access
- 3 May 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Annals of Behavioral Medicine
- Vol. 56 (1) , 50-63
Abstract
Under opt-out organ donation policies, individuals are automatically considered to have agreed to donate their organs in the absence of a recorded opt-out decision. Growing evidence suggests that the language used within organ donation campaigns influences donor intentions and decision-making. As awareness campaigns to promote opt-out consent in the UK are ongoing, the objectives of this study were to investigate the effect of language and message framing used in opt-out organ donation campaigns on donor intentions and psychological reactance. Individuals from Scotland and England (N = 1,350) completed this online experiment. Participants were randomized to view one of four messages, designed in the format of a newspaper article, which described the upcoming opt-out system. This followed a 2 × 2 design whereby the degree of threatening language (high threat vs. low threat) and message framing (loss vs. gain) of the newspaper article was experimentally manipulated. Measures of intention (pre-exposure and postexposure) and postmessage reactance (threat to freedom and anger and counter-arguing) were obtained. A mixed analysis of variance revealed a significant Group × Time interaction on donor intentions; post hoc analysis revealed that intentions significantly decreased for individuals exposed to the High threat × Loss frame article but significantly increased for those exposed to the High threat × Gain frame article. In campaigns to promote opt-out legislation, high-threat language combined with loss-frame messages should be avoided. If high-threat language is used, gain-frame messaging that highlights the benefits of organ donation should also be incorporated.Keywords
Funding Information
- Jordan Miller from the University of Stirling
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Do affective attitudes predict organ donor registration? A prospective studyJournal of Health Psychology, 2013
- Presumed Consent Legislation Failed to Improve Organ Donation in ChileTransplantation Proceedings, 2013
- A Close Examination of Trait Reactance and Issue Involvement as Moderators of Psychological Reactance TheoryJournal of Health Communication, 2011
- The “ick” factor, anticipated regret, and willingness to become an organ donor.Health Psychology, 2011
- The Role of Message Frame, Perceived Risk, and Ambivalence in Individuals' Decisions to Become Organ DonorsHealth Communication, 2010
- Examining the Use of Forceful Language When Designing Exercise Persuasive Messages for Adults: A Test of Conceptualizing Reactance Arousal as a Two-Step ProcessHealth Communication, 2008
- The Persuasive Effects of Message Framing in Organ Donation: The Mediating Role of Psychological ReactanceCommunication Monographs, 2007
- All Joking Aside: A Serious Investigation into the Persuasive Effect of Funny Social Issue MessagesCommunication Monographs, 2007
- On the Nature of Reactance and its Role in Persuasive Health CommunicationCommunication Monographs, 2005
- Message framing and sunscreen use: Gain-framed messages motivate beach-goers.Health Psychology, 1999