Temporal and Taxonomic Variability in Response of Fauna to Riparian Restoration
- 11 January 2011
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Restoration Ecology
- Vol. 19 (1) , 126-135
Abstract
Evaluating the success of restoration projects requires well‐designed studies. Among the decisions that need to be made are what taxonomic groups to study and when to conduct the monitoring. To explore how these decisions can influence assessments of restoration success, we examined species richness and composition data collected over several years on different terrestrial fauna (landbirds, rodents, bees, and beetles) at Sacramento River restoration and remnant riparian sites. Our selection of study organisms enabled us to ask whether variability in species richness among restoration sites is less for vagile taxa than for sedentary taxa, and if invertebrates display greater variability among sites than vertebrates. Our results demonstrate that responses to restoration can vary depending upon the season when it is assessed, and the taxa that are studied. For all taxa except bees, there was considerable variability in the relative performance of taxa at restoration sites from one sampling date to the next, such that the relative ranking of the sites often changed dramatically. Comparisons of β ‐diversity (variability in species richness across sites) revealed that certain taxonomic groups were more spatially variable in their response to restoration than others. Among vertebrates, sedentary taxa (rodents) had significantly higher variability in species richness across sites than highly vagile taxa (birds); however, no such pattern was observed for invertebrates. Overall, vertebrates had lower variability than invertebrates, suggesting that evaluations of restoration success based on a few better‐known taxonomic groups (e.g., birds, rodents) may be inadequate to represent the biodiversity response of other groups (e.g., insects).Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Abundance Patterns of Landbirds in Restored and Remnant Riparian Forests on the Sacramento River, California, U.S.A.Restoration Ecology, 2006
- CONSISTENCY BETWEEN ORDINATION TECHNIQUES AND DIVERSITY MEASUREMENTS: TWO STRATEGIES FOR SPECIES OCCURRENCE DATAEcology, 2003
- Monitoring and appraisal2002
- Community concordance between the fish and aquatic birds of lakes in northern Alberta, Canada: the relative importance of environmental and biotic factorsFreshwater Biology, 2000
- Restoration ecology and conservation biologyBiological Conservation, 2000
- Spatial Fidelity of Plant, Vertebrate, and Invertebrate Assemblages in Multiple‐Use Forest in Eastern AustraliaConservation Biology, 1998
- Across‐Country Analyses of Biodiversity Congruence and Current Conservation Effort in the TropicsConservation Biology, 1995
- Indicator Species and Scale of ObservationConservation Biology, 1995
- Taxonomic minimalismTrends in Ecology & Evolution, 1994
- Comparing two sets of community data: A method for testing reserve adequacyAustralian Journal of Ecology, 1992