‘Should We Kill the Grey Squirrels?’ A Study Exploring Students’ Justifications and Decision-Making
Authors:
- 1 February 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Science Education
- Vol. 34 (3) , 401-428
Abstract
A problem that is still unexplored in the field of socioscientific issues (SSI) and that was explored in this study is how different students decide upon a SSI they are discussing, how their justifications change during the instruction and how they use (or not) the evidence from the learning environment to support their justifications. For the purposes of this study, two classes (12–13-year-old students) with diverse characteristics were selected from two different schools in the UK. Class A students, considered high achievers come from a white-British background. Class B students considered average achievers come from an Asian British background. The students engaged in discussions regarding a SSI (Should we kill the grey squirrel to save the red?), supported by an online learning environment. Students’ written arguments, classroom discussions, and classroom observations were collected and analysed. The findings suggest that even though the two classes engaged with the same learning environment, the decisions and justifications provided by the pairs in the two classes were quite distinct. The students used the evidence from the learning environment in ways which supported their decision, and tended to ignore evidence if these contradicted their decision. Furthermore, students’ justifications support the hypothesis that their decision was based on whether they identified with the actors of the issue. Implications for research include exploring how students identify with the actors of a SSI to enable us to support them overcoming their personal narratives and becoming critical evaluators of scientific knowledge.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Patterns in Students’ Argumentation Confronted with a Risk‐focused Socio‐scientific IssueInternational Journal of Science Education, 2006
- Beyond STS: A research-based framework for socioscientific issues educationScience Education, 2005
- TAPping into argumentation: Developments in the application of Toulmin's Argument Pattern for studying science discourseScience Education, 2004
- Dialogic inquiry in life science conversations of family groups in a museumJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2003
- Conceptual and Epistemic Aspects of Students' Scientific ExplanationsJournal of the Learning Sciences, 2003
- 'To trust or not to trust,…'-pupils' ways of judging information encountered in a socio-scientific issueInternational Journal of Science Education, 2001
- Achieving Coordination in Collaborative Problem-Solving GroupsJournal of the Learning Sciences, 2000
- Pupil decision‐making about socio‐scientific issues within the science curriculumInternational Journal of Science Education, 1997
- Science as argument: Implications for teaching and learning scientific thinkingScience Education, 1993
- Multisite Qualitative Policy Research: Optimizing Description and GeneralizabilityEducational Researcher, 1983