A Substantivist Construal of Discourse Ethics
Author:
- 1 September 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Philosophical Studies
- Vol. 13 (3) , 405-437
Abstract
This paper presents a substantivist construal of discourse ethics, which claims that we should see our engagement in public deliberation as expressing and elaborating a substantive commitment to basic moral ideas of solidarity, equality, and freedom. This view is different from Habermas’s standard formalist defence of discourse ethics, which attempts to derive the principle of discursive moral justification from primarily non‐moral presuppositions of rational argumentation as such. After explicating the difference between the substantivist and the formalist construal, I defend the former by showing that it is not only intuitively compelling, but also particularly well equipped for addressing four important objections recently levelled against discourse ethics and its political applications (Rawls’s concern that it lacks substantive guidelines, Gunnarsson’s challenge that it has not been proven to be superior to alternative moral conceptions such as utilitarianism, Scanlon’s complaint that it lacks an account of moral motivation, and Galston’s and Young’s worries that it could lead to political practices of cultural imposition). I conclude by pointing out some consequences of the previous discussion for the future of Critical Theory.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- SHOULD DISCOURSE ETHICS DO WITHOUT A PRINCIPLE OF UNIVERSALIZATION?The Philosophical Forum, 2005
- The substantive dimension of deliberative practical rationalityPhilosophy & Social Criticism, 2005
- The Duty to Eradicate Global Poverty: Positive or Negative?Ethical Theory and Moral Practice, 2005
- Moral Objectivity and Reasonable Agreement: Can Realism Be Reconciled with Kantian Constructivism?Ratio Juris, 2004
- Reasonable Reasons in Contractualist Moral ArgumentEthics, 2003
- Communicative Action and Rational Choice2001
- Making Moral Sense2000
- Modernity and Morality in Habermas's Discourse EthicsInquiry, 2000
- Reflections on Habermas on DemocracyRatio Juris, 1999
- The Basic Right to Justification: Towards a Constructivist Conception of Human RightsConstellations, 1999