(Re)constructing the Pipeline: Workers, Environmentalists and Ideology in Media Coverage of the Keystone XL Pipeline
Author:
- 20 August 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Critical Sociology
- Vol. 43 (6) , 893-917
Abstract
Environmental protection is presumed to damper economic growth and media accounts of resource extraction often portray trade-offs between jobs and the environment. However, there is limited evidence that environmental protection universally costs jobs and heavily polluting industries provide few jobs in comparison to environmental impacts. Therefore, how has media discourse contributed to the taken-for-granted division between the economy and the environment? This paper uses the Keystone XL pipeline controversy as a case of the symbolical conflict between supporters of growth and conservation to explore the role of ideology and power in media discourse. I use frame analysis of newspaper articles to explore the representations of labor and the environment and how hegemonic ideology legitimizes resource extraction. My analysis reveals binary framing that constructed the pipeline as a political controversy over the trade-off between the environment and the economy, which made conflict between workers and environmentalists sensible, and silenced alternatives.Keywords
This publication has 70 references indexed in Scilit:
- Economic Growth and the Diffusion of Clean Technologies: Explaining Environmental Kuznets CurvesEnvironmental and Resource Economics, 2010
- Labor-Environmental Coalition Formation: Framing and the Right to Know1Sociological Forum, 2010
- Privileged Access, Privileged Accounts: Toward a Socially Structured Theory of Resources and DiscoursesSocial Forces, 2005
- Labor‐Environmental Relations: An Analysis of the Relationship between Labor Unions and EnvironmentalistsSocial Science Quarterly, 2002
- Labor‐community alliances in petrochemical regions in the United States and Brazil: What does it take to win?Capitalism Nature Socialism, 2000
- Contesting the hegemony of market ideology: Gramsci's 'good sense' and Polanyi's 'double movement'Review of International Political Economy, 1999
- Remapping North American environmentalism: Contending visions and divergent practices in the fight over NAFTA∗Capitalism Nature Socialism, 1997
- Framing: Toward Clarification of a Fractured ParadigmJournal of Communication, 1993
- The limits of environmentalism without class: Lessons from the ancient forest struggle of the pacific Northwest∗Capitalism Nature Socialism, 1993
- Capitalism, nature, socialism a theoretical introduction∗Capitalism Nature Socialism, 1988