A framework for causal estimand selection under positivity violations
- 6 January 2026
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Biometrics
- Vol. 82 (1)
Abstract
Estimating the causal effect of a treatment or health policy with observational data can be challenging due to an imbalance of and a lack of overlap between treated and control covariate distributions. In the presence of limited overlap, researchers choose between (1) methods (e.g., inverse probability weighting) that imply traditional estimands but whose estimators are at risk of considerable bias and variance; and (2) methods (e.g., overlap weighting) which imply a different estimand by modifying the target population to reduce variance. We propose a framework for navigating the tradeoffs between variance and bias due to imbalance and a lack of overlap and the targeting of the estimand of scientific interest. We introduce a bias decomposition that encapsulates bias due to (1) the statistical bias of the estimator; and (2) estimand mismatch, i.e., deviation from the population of interest. We propose two design-based metrics and an estimand selection procedure that help illustrate the tradeoffs between these sources of bias and variance of the resulting estimators. Our procedure allows analysts to incorporate their domain-specific preference for preservation of the original research population versus reduction of statistical bias. We demonstrate how to select an estimand based on these preferences with an application to right heart catheterization data.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship Program (2237827)
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Health disparities in the treatment of bipolar disorderPersonalized Medicine in Psychiatry, 2023
- Disparities in the Prescription of Statins in the Primary Care Setting: A Retrospective Observational StudyCurrent Problems in Cardiology, 2022
- Balancing vs modeling approaches to weighting in practiceStatistics in Medicine, 2020
- Balancing Covariates via Propensity Score WeightingJournal of the American Statistical Association, 2017
- Stable Weights that Balance Covariates for Estimation With Incomplete Outcome DataJournal of the American Statistical Association, 2015
- Dealing with limited overlap in estimation of average treatment effectsBiometrika, 2009
- Estimation of Causal Effects using Propensity Score Weighting: An Application to Data on Right Heart CatheterizationHealth Services and Outcomes Research Methodology, 2001
- The Effectiveness of Right Heart Catheterization in the Initial Care of Critically III PatientsJAMA, 1996
- The central role of the propensity score in observational studies for causal effectsBiometrika, 1983
- Estimating causal effects of treatments in randomized and nonrandomized studies.Journal of Educational Psychology, 1974