Higher education institutions worldwide faced significant disruption and chaos as COVID-19 swept away the normal in 2020, catapulting them into online mode of instruction with hardly any transitional time. It can be argued that the challenge was particularly daunting for universities in developing country contexts of South Asia, like Pakistan, with limited resources and a large student body coming from socioeconomically disadvantaged backgrounds. While research evidence piled up around the world about different challenges that specific universities faced within or across countries, there has been little systematic work done to explore the comparative challenges faced by universities in urban (large metropolitan) and rural (smaller/semi-urban /cities) in a single country context. This paper presents the findings of a large-scale survey sent to all the universities in Pakistan during COVID to understand the intra-country variation that one needs to keep in mind as we prepare for online instruction to meet similar challenges in the future. A quantitative survey was sent to 196 universities in Pakistan. The survey had questions under the following categories, namely: university readiness, faculty readiness, student readiness, technology readiness and laboratory readiness. The results presented here are from 170 universities. The results reveal that urban universities were much more successful in their transition to online instruction than rural universities. The disparities were across: a) the extent of online policy adoption; b) infrastructure and support; c) operationalization of online teaching processes; and d) student and faculty readiness for online instruction. The study in the developing country context of the global South contributes to the relevant literature by providing insights into the unique challenges faced by universities because of their location.