Subjective evaluation of spatial analysis and synthesis methods using different microphone arrays
Authors:
- 8 September 2021
- conference paper
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 1-7
Abstract
Multiple spatial analysis and synthesis methods were proposed up to this date, however, there is still a lack of scientific evidence to conclude how proposed methods and measurement setups compare to each other. This paper presents a subjective study that investigates how spatial analysis and synthesis method affects spatial and timbral fidelities of the binaural renderings for three different stimuli and three source positions. Evaluated positions: (a) +30°, (b) +90°, (c) +135° were motivated by the 4+7+0 loudspeaker layout from the ITU-R BS.2051-2 recommendation. Spatial room impulse responses were measured in the ITU-R BS.1116-compliant listening room using two different microphone arrays. Measurements were used to create auralisations from Spatial Decomposition Method (SDM) and Higher-Order Spatial Impulse Response Rendering (HO-SIRR). The test conditions were selected to investigate: (i) rendering method (ii) direction of arrival (DOA) estimation method, (iii) microphone array, (iv) use of a dedicated centre reference microphone with SDM and (v) band-pass filtering of the spatial room impulse responses prior to the TDOA-based DOA estimation and DOA enforcement for the direct sound. The listening experiment followed MUSHRA-like methodology with a hidden reference, employing a five-grade similarity scale. Subjects’ task was to evaluate how similar the test conditions are to the reference (measured BRIR) with regard to the assessed attribute. This article includes a short review of the existing methods, describes the experimental design and presents the results of the formal listening tests followed by the discussion.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Effect of Direct-to-Reverberant Energy Ratio on Front-Back Confusion in Binaural Reproduction2021
- Optimizations of the Spatial Decomposition Method for Binaural ReproductionJournal of the Audio Engineering Society, 2021
- Higher-Order Spatial Impulse Response Rendering: Investigating the Perceived Effects of Spherical Order, Dedicated Diffuse Rendering, and Frequency ResolutionJournal of the Audio Engineering Society, 2020
- Perceptual Evaluation of Binaural Auralization of Data Obtained from the Spatial Decomposition Method2019
- Auralization of Omnidirectional Room Impulse Responses Based on the Spatial Decomposition Method and Synthetic Spatial Data2019
- Spatial analysis and auralization of room acoustics using a tetrahedral microphoneThe Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 2017
- Spatial Analysis and Synthesis of Car Audio System and Car Cabin Acoustics with a Compact Microphone ArrayJournal of the Audio Engineering Society, 2015
- Preferences of Critical Listening Environments Among Sound EngineersJournal of the Audio Engineering Society, 2014
- Analysis of concert hall acoustics via visualizations of time-frequency and spatiotemporal responsesThe Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 2013
- Image method for efficiently simulating small-room acousticsThe Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 1979