Physician Turnover in Eight New England Prepaid Group Practices: An Analysis

Authors:
  • SMStephen S. Mick
    Stephen S. Mick
  • SSSheldon Sussman
    Sheldon Sussman
  • LALydia Anderson-Selling
    Lydia Anderson-Selling
  • CDCarlos DelNero
    Carlos DelNero
  • RGRobert Glazer
    Robert Glazer
  • EHElizabeth Hirsch
    Elizabeth Hirsch
  • DRDaniel S. Rowe
    Daniel S. Rowe

Abstract
The objectives of this questionnaire study of all primary care physicians (N = 154) who had ever worked in eight New England prepaid group practices (PGPs) include 1) calculation of turnover rates, 2) comparison of those who stayed in (stayers) versus those who left (leavers) the PGPs, and 3) description of reasons given for leaving. An annual turnover rate of 3.9 to 6.3 per cent, depending upon the measure, was within the range reported by others. Factors associated with stayer-leaver status were experiences before and during the physician's PGP tenure. Leavers reported pre-PGP experience in fee-for-service, hospital-based, and academic positions, and while in the PGPs, they reported constraints on autonomy, independence, and professional development. Leavers reported higher incomes and longer working hours in their new practices. They cited the potential for greater autonomy as the reason for leaving. The findings and study limitations are discussed.