Abstract
Electrolysis is regarded as a cornerstone of the energy transition, decarbonising hard-to-abate sectors and enabling flexible sector-coupling between electricity and hydrogen systems. However, output-based subsidies – such as fixed premia awarded by the European Commission – may misalign electrolyser operational incentives and system needs. This study quantifies the distortion induced by a fixed premium on dispatch incentives through a detailed optimisation case study of electricity-hydrogen system operation for sixteen European countries in 2040. Results indicate that electrolysis becomes less sensitive to short-term price signals as the premium grows. It gradually reduces its flexibility provision, in particular on the weekly and annual timescales. This flexibility downgrade is largely replaced by mid-merit thermal generation, notably from natural gas, resulting in increased costs, emissions, and fossil fuel consumption. These effects are heterogeneous across Europe, shaped by cross-border infrastructure and the geographic distribution of electrolysis and mid-merit generation capacities. Our findings raise policymaker awareness on the long-term impacts of currently issued electrolysis subsidies on future energy system operation and on EU dependence on fuel imports. It stresses the need to safeguard electrolysis flexibility incentives to efficiently reach net zero. Policymakers should acknowledge the distortive potential of electrolysis subsidies, and design support schemes that preserve efficient short-term economic signals, accounting for the lock-in that subsidy choices induce.