Therapist-guided remote versus in-person cognitive behavioural therapy: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials
Authors:
- Sara ZandiehSZSara Zandieh
- Seyedeh Maryam AbdollahzadehSASeyedeh Maryam Abdollahzadeh
- Behnam SadeghiradBSBehnam Sadeghirad
- Li WangLWLi Wang
- Randi E. McCabeRMRandi E. McCabe
- Liam YaoLYLiam Yao
- Briar E. InnessBIBriar E. Inness
- Ananya PathakAPAnanya Pathak
- Rachel J. CoubanRCRachel J. Couban
- Holly CrandonHCHolly Crandon
- Kian TorabiardakaniKTKian Torabiardakani
- Peter BielingPBPeter Bieling
Top Cited Papers
Open Access
- 17 March 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by CMA Impact Inc. in Canadian Medical Association Journal
- Vol. 196 (10) , E327-E340
Abstract
Background: Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) has been shown to be effective for several psychiatric and somatic conditions; however, most randomized controlled trials (RCTs) have administered treatment in person and whether remote delivery is similarly effective remains uncertain. We sought to compare the effectiveness of therapist-guided remote CBT and in-person CBT. Methods: We systematically searched MEDLINE, Embase, PsycINFO, CINAHL, and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials from inception to July 4, 2023, for RCTs that enrolled adults (aged ≥ 18 yr) presenting with any clinical condition and that randomized participants to either therapist-guided remote CBT (e.g., teleconference, videoconference) or in-person CBT. Paired reviewers assessed risk of bias and extracted data independently and in duplicate. We performed random-effects model meta-analyses to pool patient-important primary outcomes across eligible RCTs as standardized mean differences (SMDs). We used Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) guidance to assess the certainty of evidence and used the Instrument to Assess the Credibility of Effect Modification Analyses (ICEMAN) to rate the credibility of subgroup effects. Results: We included 54 RCTs that enrolled a total of 5463 patients. Seventeen studies focused on treatment of anxiety and related disorders, 14 on depressive symptoms, 7 on insomnia, 6 on chronic pain or fatigue syndromes, 5 on body image or eating disorders, 3 on tinnitus, 1 on alcohol use disorder, and 1 on mood and anxiety disorders. Moderate-certainty evidence showed little to no difference in the effectiveness of therapist-guided remote and in-person CBT on primary outcomes (SMD −0.02, 95% confidence interval −0.12 to 0.07). Interpretation: Moderate-certainty evidence showed little to no difference in the effectiveness of in-person and therapist-guided remote CBT across a range of mental health and somatic disorders, suggesting potential for the use of therapist-guided remote CBT to facilitate greater access to evidence-based care. Systematic review registration: Open Science Framework (https://osf.io/7asrc)Keywords
This publication has 101 references indexed in Scilit:
- Internet‐delivered psychological treatments: from innovation to implementationWorld Psychiatry, 2019
- The third wave of cognitive behavioral therapy and the rise of process‐based careWorld Psychiatry, 2017
- Guided Internet-based vs. face-to-face cognitive behavior therapy for psychiatric and somatic disorders: a systematic review and meta-analysisWorld Psychiatry, 2014
- A randomized controlled trial of an Internet‐based cognitive–behavioural intervention for non‐specific chronic pain: An effectiveness and cost‐effectiveness studyEuropean journal of pain, 2014
- SIX-MONTH POSTINTERVENTION DEPRESSION AND DISABILITY OUTCOMES OF IN-HOME TELEHEALTH PROBLEM-SOLVING THERAPY FOR DEPRESSED, LOW-INCOME HOMEBOUND OLDER ADULTSDepression and Anxiety, 2014
- Effect of Telephone-Administered vs Face-to-face Cognitive Behavioral Therapy on Adherence to Therapy and Depression Outcomes Among Primary Care PatientsJAMA, 2012
- A randomized trial of internet‐based versus traditional sexual counseling for couples after localized prostate cancer treatmentCancer, 2011
- Pooling health‐related quality of life outcomes in meta‐analysis—a tutorial and review of methods for enhancing interpretabilityResearch Synthesis Methods, 2011
- Graphical displays for meta‐analysis: An overview with suggestions for practiceResearch Synthesis Methods, 2010
- Comparison of face‐to‐face and internet interventions for body image and eating problems in adult women: An RCTInternational Journal of Eating Disorders, 2007