An Anatomy of the SoR: A Systematic Review of the Conceptualizations and Instrumental Uses of the Science of Reading
Top Cited Papers
Open Access
- 18 February 2026
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Reading Research Quarterly
- Vol. 61 (2)
Abstract
In this systematic review, evolving conceptualizations and instrumental uses of the “science of reading” (SoR) in educational literature from 2017 to 2025 were investigated. Amid renewed discussions reminiscent of historical “reading wars,” the SoR has emerged as a dominant discourse in literacy education, shaped by media, policy, and scholarly engagement. Drawing on 121 researcher and practitioner‐oriented articles analyzed through a PRISMA‐informed review and coding process, we identified seven conceptualizations of the SoR, ranging from narrow phonics‐based definitions to broader, multifaceted interpretations encompassing comprehension, equity, multilingualism, and sociocultural contexts. The study reveals that while over 90% of articles acknowledge narrow interpretations, nearly half also present broader perspectives, highlighting tensions and complexities within the field. Authors frequently use the SoR to introduce articles, frame arguments, and validate pedagogical models, with 93.8% employing multiple uses. The findings also underscore a disconnect between research and practitioner publications, with nuanced definitions more prevalent in scholarly work. This divergence has implications for policy, curriculum, and instructional practices, as these various portrayals in discourse risk marginalizing diverse literacy needs. This review calls for a fourth Reading Research Quarterly special issue to critically examine how the SoR shapes educational mandates, practices, and politics. Given the dual role of the SoR as both a construct and a rhetorical tool, the study emphasizes the need for ongoing critical inquiry into the politicization of the SoR and its impact on literacy education, advocating for inclusive and evidence‐informed approaches to reading instruction.Keywords
This publication has 96 references indexed in Scilit:
- Does English Have Useful Syllable Division Patterns?Reading Research Quarterly, 2020
- Lost in Translation? Challenges in Connecting Reading Science and Educational PracticeReading Research Quarterly, 2020
- Reading Wars, Reading Science, and English LearnersReading Research Quarterly, 2020
- Interconnected Infrastructure for Improving Reading InstructionReading Research Quarterly, 2020
- The Cognitive Element Model of Reading InstructionReading Research Quarterly, 2020
- The Sciences of Reading and Writing Must Become More Fully IntegratedReading Research Quarterly, 2020
- Building Content Knowledge to Boost Comprehension in the Primary GradesReading Research Quarterly, 2020
- What Research Has Revealed About Readers’ Struggles With Comprehension in the Digital Age: Moving Beyond the Phonics Versus Whole Language DebateReading Research Quarterly, 2020
- How the Reading for Understanding Initiative’s Research Complicates the Simple View of Reading Invoked in the Science of ReadingReading Research Quarterly, 2020
- Effectiveness of Literacy Programs Balancing Reading and Writing Instruction: A Meta‐AnalysisReading Research Quarterly, 2017