Comparison of clinical metagenomics with 16S rDNA Sanger sequencing for the bacteriological diagnosis of culture-negative samples
Authors:
Preprint
Abstract
Background Currently, diagnosis of bacterial infections is based on culture, possibly followed by the amplification and sequencing (Sanger method) of the 16S rDNA - encoding gene when cultures are negative. Clinical metagenomics (CMg), i.e. the sequencing of a sample’s entire nucleic acids, may allow for the identification of bacteria not detected by conventional methods. Here, we tested the performance of CMg compared to 16S rDNA sequencing (Sanger) in 50 patients with suspected bacterial infection but negative cultures. Methods This is a prospective cohort study. Fifty patients (73 samples) with negative culture and a 16S rDNA sequencing demand (Sanger) were recruited from two sites. On the same samples, CMg was also performed and compared to 16S rDNA Sanger sequencing. Bacteria were identified using MetaPhlAn4. Results Among the 73 samples, 20 (27.4%, 17 patients) had a clinically significant 16S rDNA Sanger sequencing result (used for patient management) while 11 (15.1%, 9 patients) were considered contaminants. At the patient level, the sensitivity of CMg was 70.1% (12/17) compared to 16S rDNA. In samples negative for 16S rDNA Sanger sequencing (n=53), CMg identified clinically-relevant bacteria in 10 samples (18.9%, 10 patients) with 14 additional bacteria. Conclusions CMg was not 100% sensitive when compared to 16S, supporting that it may not be a suitable replacement. However, CMg did find additional bacteria in samples negative for 16S rDNA Sanger. CMg could therefore be positioned as a complementary to 16S rDNA Sanger sequencing.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: International Journal of Medical Microbiology, 318, 151650.
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Metagenomic DNA sequencing for semi-quantitative pathogen detection from urine: a prospective, laboratory-based, proof-of-concept studyThe Lancet Microbe, 2022
- Diagnostic Value of 16S Ribosomal RNA Gene Polymerase Chain Reaction/Sanger Sequencing in Clinical PracticeClinical Infectious Diseases, 2021
- The Potential Role of Clinical Metagenomics in Infectious Diseases: Therapeutic PerspectivesDrugs, 2021
- Rapid pathogen detection by metagenomic next-generation sequencing of infected body fluidsNature Medicine, 2020
- Clinical metagenomicsNature Reviews Genetics, 2019
- Critical Assessment of Metagenome Interpretation—a benchmark of metagenomics softwareNature Methods, 2017
- Clinical metagenomics of bone and joint infections: a proof of concept studyScientific Reports, 2017
- MetaPhlAn2 for enhanced metagenomic taxonomic profilingNature Methods, 2015
- QUAST: quality assessment tool for genome assembliesBioinformatics, 2013
- Fast gapped-read alignment with Bowtie 2Nature Methods, 2012