Abstract
High predicted target compound content does not ensure that an extraction condition will also meet composition requirements. This retrospective benchmark tested whether composition screening increased successful recommendations compared with selection based on predicted content alone. The evidence base included 39 datasets from 28 studies, with separate extensions. Within datasets, polynomial regression, Gaussian process, and tree ensemble models predicted component responses at held-out measured conditions. Both selection rules were evaluated against identical training-derived content and panel-share requirements. Attainment was the proportion of evaluation problems yielding a successful recommendation. Across seven original primary datasets, the median-share constraint increased attainment in only three of 35 focal dataset–model comparisons on common sets, by at most 1.4 percentage points. In grape pomace, reduced quadratic regression gained eight successes through candidate switching but lost 60, including 45 through additional abstention. Medicinal plant evidence meeting primary-analysis criteria was limited to saffron and sage herbal dust, with source-specific qualifications. These findings support jointly evaluating attainment, coverage, conditional violation rates, and model availability. By distinguishing unsuitable recommendations from missed suitable conditions, the benchmark supports comparison of selection strategies and prioritization of extraction conditions for prospective validation across independent batches, informing ingredient and process development for industrial applications.

This publication has 80 references indexed in Scilit: