The limits of “ordre public” and “morality” for the patentability of human embryonic stem cell inventions
Author:
- 19 July 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in The Journal of World Intellectual Property
- Vol. 22 (1-2) , 2-15
Abstract
Inventions involving human embryonic stem cells (hESC) have unprecedented potential to improve human life through discovery of new drugs and treatment of incurable neurodegenerative diseases, but at the same time, the use of human embryos in research gives rise to contrasting ethical, moral and religious views on the patentability of such inventions. Whether and to what extent patent offices should take these views into account is an open question. The “ordre public” and “morality” clause in patent law may help us find an answer, but neither the legislator nor courts have clarified the meaning of these vague terms. Judicial interpretation has sometimes increased their ambiguity and raised legal uncertainty for the patentability of hESC inventions. This situation may be desirable in some cases, but not in others where the principles of the legal system as a whole come into play. This paper will shed light on the meaning of “ordre public” and “morality” for hESC inventions by examining patent law in the broader legal framework and emphasizing the interconnectedness of national legal systems in a global market as well as the common interest in healthcare innovations.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Life-Form Patents: Proceedings in the European Patent Office and the Role of Non-commercial Parties2019
- Interspecies Chimerism with Mammalian Pluripotent Stem CellsCell, 2017
- The dynamic state of patents in regenerative medicineTissue Engineering and Regenerative Medicine, 2013
- Exclusions from Patentability2012
- Quand nos aînés déclarent la dépendance (introduction)Revue Projet, 2012
- Maximising Permissible Exceptions to Intellectual Property Rights2011
- Can Patent Legislation Make a Difference? Bringing Parliaments and Civil Society into Patent Governance2009
- Paying for particulars in people-to-be: commercialisation, commodification and commensurability in human reproductionJournal of Medical Ethics, 2008
- Holzapfel-Meyers-Nicolaou Modification of the Hantzsch Thiazole SynthesisSynthesis, 2007
- The Law of ObligationsRoman Foundations of the Civilian Tradition1996