Familiar ethical issues amplified: how members of research ethics committees describe ethical distinctions between disaster and non-disaster research
Open Access
- 28 June 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Ethics
- Vol. 18 (1) , 1-12
Abstract
The conduct of research in settings affected by disasters such as hurricanes, floods and earthquakes is challenging, particularly when infrastructures and resources were already limited pre-disaster. However, since post-disaster research is essential to the improvement of the humanitarian response, it is important that adequate research ethics oversight be available. We aim to answer the following questions: 1) what do research ethics committee (REC) members who have reviewed research protocols to be conducted following disasters in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) perceive as the key ethical concerns associated with disaster research?, and 2) in what ways do REC members understand these concerns to be distinct from those arising in research conducted in non-crisis situations? This qualitative study was developed using interpretative description methodology; 15 interviews were conducted with REC members. Four key ethical issues were identified as presenting distinctive considerations for disaster research to be implemented in LMICs, and were described by participants as familiar research ethics issues that were amplified in these contexts. First, REC members viewed disaster research as having strong social value due to its potential for improving disaster response, but also as requiring a higher level of justification compared to other research settings. Second, they identified vulnerability as an overarching concern for disaster research ethics, and a feature that required careful and critical appraisal when assessing protocols. They noted that research participants’ vulnerabilities frequently change in the aftermath of a disaster and often in unpredictable ways. Third, they identified concerns related to promoting and maintaining safety, confidentiality and data security in insecure or austere environments. Lastly, though REC members endorsed the need and usefulness of community engagement, they noted that there are significant challenges in a disaster setting over and above those typically encountered in global health research to achieve meaningful community engagement. Disaster research presents distinctive ethical considerations that require attention to ensure that participants are protected. As RECs review disaster research protocols, they should address these concerns and consider how justification, vulnerability, security and confidentially, and community engagement are shaped by the realities of conducting research in a disaster.Keywords
Funding Information
- Canadian Institutes of Health Research (EOG 123679)
- Santé (Research Scholar Award)
- Arnold Johnson Chair in Healthcare Ethics at McMaster University
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Ethics of emergent information and communication technology applications in humanitarian medical assistanceInternational Health, 2016
- The Challenge of Timely, Responsive and Rigorous Ethics Review of Disaster Research: Views of Research Ethics Committee MembersPLOS ONE, 2016
- Healthcare needs of displaced women: Osire refugee camp, NamibiaInternational Nursing Review, 2016
- Innovations in research ethics governance in humanitarian settingsBMC Medical Ethics, 2015
- Community engagement and the human infrastructure of global health researchBMC Medical Ethics, 2014
- Natural Disasters, Armed Conflict, and Public HealthNew England Journal of Medicine, 2013
- A framework for research ethics review during public emergenciesCanadian Medical Association Journal, 2010
- Conducting research in the aftermath of disasters: ethical considerationsJournal of Evidence-Based Medicine, 2010
- Research Ethics Review in Humanitarian Contexts: The Experience of the Independent Ethics Review Board of Médecins Sans FrontièresPLOS Medicine, 2009
- Ethical challenges in conducting research in humanitarian crisis situationsMalawi Medical Journal, 2008