Who counts as a woman? A critical discourse analysis of petitions against the participation of transgender athletes in women's sport
- 13 August 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Review for the Sociology of Sport
- Vol. 59 (2) , 203-221
Abstract
This article aims to analyze the organizational anti-trans discourse on the presence of transgender athletes in women's sport. To achieve this, the petitions published from 2019 to 2022 on the websites of three US organizations (Save Women's Sports, Independent Council on Women's Sports, and the Women's Sports Policy Working Group) were analyzed. The analysis addressed the research questions of how this discourse defines trans women and trans bodies and reproduces the indispensability of sex segregation in sport competitions. The research revealed that the petitions’ authors identified trans athletes as biological males who have an advantage over cis women. The organizations demand that the protection of women's sport from trans women's participation and women's rights be based on the sex (assigned at birth) category. The article emphasizes that members and allies of these organizations perceive biomedical science as providing objective arguments for the sex dichotomy and the exclusion of trans women from sport competitions. At the same time, the petitions’ authors ignore sociocultural factors that influence the perception of gender dichotomy and athletic performance.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Sport and Transgender People: A Systematic Review of the Literature Relating to Sport Participation and Competitive Sport PoliciesSports Medicine, 2016
- Bathroom Battlegrounds and Penis PanicsContexts, 2015
- Beyond fairness: the ethics of inclusion for transgender and intersex athletesJournal of the Philosophy of Sport, 2015
- The Technical Capacities of the BodyTSQ: Transgender Studies Quarterly, 2014
- Spectacles and Scholarship: Caster Semenya, Intersex Studies, and the Problem of Race in Feminist TheorySigns: Journal of Women in Culture and Society, 2014
- Doing Gender, Determining GenderGender & Society, 2013
- Gender Verification and Gender Policies in Elite SportJournal of Sport and Social Issues, 2011
- Online petitions: new tools of secondary analysis?Qualitative Research, 2010
- “Run, Caster Semenya, Run!” Nativism and the Translations of Gender VarianceSafundi, 2010
- Transsexual and Transgender Policies in SportWomen in Sport and Physical Activity Journal, 2006