The Wicked Problem the Water Framework Directive Cannot Solve. The Governance Approach in Dealing with Pollution of Nutrients in Surface Water in the Netherlands, Flanders, Lower Saxony, Denmark and Ireland
Open Access
Abstract
The Water Framework Directive (WFD) is typically a framework directive that tries to encourage integration of policies for water quality and agriculture. Nutrients (nitrates, phosphates) from agricultural sources remain a ‘wicked problem’ in realizing the aims of the WFD, partly because the directive has to rely on other, neighboring policies to tackle to problem pressure of nutrients; it seems to lack instruments and measures to directly intervene in relevant agricultural policies. This contribution describes the different governance approaches of five member states and regions (The Netherlands, Flanders in Belgium, Lower Saxony- in Germany, Denmark and Ireland) to the nutrients problem and specifically focuses on the relationship between the nature of governance and the nature of measures taken. On the one hand, countries can vary in terms of a more consensual or antagonistic approach to dealing with water quality and diffuse pollution by agriculture, and emphasize more integration or separation in organization and programs. On the other hand, they can vary in the ‘outcomes’ in terms of more source-based measures or effect-based measures and the emphasis in policy instruments used. This article is based on the screening of policy documents, 44 interviews and several (international) feedback workshops. We found a great variety in governance approaches, while the nature of measures, in terms of source-based and effect-based, is only slightly different. On closer inspection, there are interesting differences in the consensual or antagonist discourses and differences in the use of more mandatory instruments or area-based policies. In many countries, the major challenge is to strike a balance between taking source-based measures, where necessary, and accommodating the difficult situations farmers very often find themselves in, as the reduction of nutrients (as a source-based measure) use can lead to lower yields and higher costs for manure disposal.Keywords
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- Spatial Fit, from Panacea to Practice: Implementing the EU Water Framework DirectiveEcology and Society, 2012
- The EU Water Framework Directive: A multi-dimensional analysis of implementation and domestic impactLand Use Policy, 2011
- Reconceptualising the ‘policy mix’ for innovationResearch Policy, 2011
- The European Water Framework Directive at the age of 10: A critical review of the achievements with recommendations for the futureScience of The Total Environment, 2010
- The Water Framework Directive and agricultural nitrate pollution: will great expectations in Brussels be dashed in Lower Saxony?European Environment, 2007
- Introduction: Understanding Public Policy through Its Instruments—From the Nature of Instruments to the Sociology of Public Policy InstrumentationGovernance, 2007
- Intellectual Obsolescence and Intellectual Makeovers: Reflections on the Tools of Government after Two DecadesGovernance, 2007
- Policy Instrument Choice and Diffuse Source PollutionJournal of Environmental Law, 2005
- AGRICULTURE, ENVIRONMENT AND THE STATE: The development of agro‐environmental policy‐making in the NetherlandsSociologia Ruralis, 1993
- The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional Isomorphism and Collective Rationality in Organizational FieldsAmerican Sociological Review, 1983