A comparison of voluntary and involuntary patients admitted to hospital
Authors:
- Siobhan RooneySRSiobhan Rooney
- Kieran C MurphyKMKieran C Murphy
- 1 March 1996
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Irish Journal of Psychological Medicine
- Vol. 13 (4) , 132-138
Abstract
Objectives: In view of the apparent public discontent that has been expressed by individuals towards temporary certification and involuntary treatment, this study was set up to assess patients' reactions to their involuntary admission. The study compared the demographic characteristics of voluntary and involuntary patients and assessed their attitudes towards and knowledge of the certification process that presently exists in Ireland.Method: A total of 68 patients, 38 involuntary patients consecutively admitted over a six month period and 30 voluntary patients selected over the same period, were interviewed with a standard questionnaire, on average six months after discharge.Results: Involuntary patients were more likely to be single, live with their families and showed no demonstrable gender bias. Involuntary patients had limited knowledge of specific aspects of their individual certifications, particularly with regard to knowledge of their rights, admission status and knowledge of the identity of the applicant of the certificate. Of these, 10% were aware of their rights on admission and only 14% could recall that their rights had been explained to them on admission.Conclusion: Although patients initially expressed strong feelings of anger on admission towards committal, these feelings were found to reduce over time. Recommendations for improving the present Mental Health Act were suggested by those interviewed and these included a need for an initial assessment period before certification is completed and a need for improved communication by medical staff regarding information on the admission status, the identity of the applicant and on the person's rights.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- Medical and social paternalism Regulation of and attitudes towards compulsory psychiatric careActa Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 1993
- Involuntary admissions to a district mental health service – implications for a new mental treatment actIrish Journal of Psychological Medicine, 1993
- Attitudes of Psychiatric Patients and their Relatives to Involuntary TreatmentAustralian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 1991
- Change with Time in Patients’ Reactions to CommittalThe Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 1986
- Patients’ Attitudes at the Time of Their CommitmentThe Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 1984
- Attitudinal Changes of Involuntarily Committed Patients Following TreatmentArchives of General Psychiatry, 1983
- Patients’ Reactions to Their CommitmentThe Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 1981
- Patient satisfaction and involuntary treatment.American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 1980
- A Comparison of Voluntary and Committed Psychiatric PatientsArchives of General Psychiatry, 1977
- Patient comments about hospitalization: Implications for changeComprehensive Psychiatry, 1976