The Settlement‐Orientation vs. the Problem‐Solving Style in Custody Mediation
Authors:
- 14 April 1994
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Social Issues
- Vol. 50 (1) , 67-84
Abstract
While empirical studies have generally demonstrated the value of mediation in divorce, little research has been conducted on the specific models of mediation that are most efficacious in such disputes. This article reports the results of an intensive analysis of 32 cases of custody mediation conducted at the Essex County (NJ) Family Court. One‐half of the cases represented predivorce parental disputes; one‐half were postdivorce disputes. Nearly half of the cases were characterized by extremely high levels of parental conflict. Mediator behavior was assessed in one 1 1/2–2‐hour closing case conferences, supplemented by the examination of audio or video recordings of mediation in 62% of the cases. The effectiveness of mediation was assessed by a postmediation telephone interview and by an analysis of court records, both conducted approximately 18 months after the termination of mediation. Two contrasting styles of enacting the mediator role were identified: The settlement‐oriented style (SOS) and the problem‐solving style (PSS). Mediators tended to use one or the other style. The SOS mediators were primarily concerned with getting a “settlement” and staying “neutral”; PSS mediators were more focused on understanding the causes of the conflict through persistent question asking and were willing to depart from strict “neutrality” in cases where the conflict was being fueled by particularly destructive behaviors in one of the parents. SOS was the mediator style in 59% of the cases, PSS in 41%. Compared to SOS, PSS produced a more structured and vigorous approach to conflict resolution during mediation, more frequent and durable settlements, and a generally more favorable attitude toward the mediation experience. SOS was not necessarily bad, but PSS was better.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- Long-term success in mediation.Law and Human Behavior, 1993
- MEDIATION CONTROL TECHNIQUES: A TEST OF KOLB'S “ORCHESTRATORS” VS. “DEALMAKERS” MODELInternational Journal of Conflict Management, 1992
- Negotiation and MediationAnnual Review of Psychology, 1992
- Putting Mediation Skills to the TestNegotiation Journal, 1990
- Research in contested custody mediations: An illustration of the case study methodMediation Quarterly, 1989
- Child custody mediation and litigation: An experimental evaluation of the experience of parents.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 1987
- Mediator Style and Mediation EffectivenessNegotiation Journal, 1986
- Mediator Settlement StrategiesLaw & Policy, 1986
- Mediating Public Disputes: Obstacles and PossibilitiesJournal of Social Issues, 1985
- The Resolution of ConflictAmerican Behavioral Scientist, 1973