Ambitious for change? A critical appraisal of the Canadian indicator framework of the sustainable development goals
Open Access
- 7 January 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Human Rights Practice
- Vol. 15 (1) , 204-231
Abstract
This article explores the indicators and targets identified in the Canadian Indicator Framework, a localization of the UN Sustainable Development Goals for the country of Canada. Applying a critical theoretical lens and a human rights approach, the authors explore each of the ‘ambitions’ proposed by the federal government and assess their suitability in meeting the magnitude of transformative change that will be necessary to meet the goals of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. In considering each of the Canadian ambitions proposed to realize Sustainable Development Goals 1 to 17, and the framework as a whole, the authors conclude that a business-as-usual stance has been applied. Many of the Canadian ambitions have ‘no specific target’ identified, offering no baseline measures or concrete standards from which to benchmark and monitor progress. The ones that do are not tremendously transformative, leading to a framework that does not present a dramatic departure from existing policy and practice arrangements. The character of the Canadian ambitions to the Sustainable Development Goals are revealed, not as concrete change strategies, but as mere aspirations, albeit more for the status quo than for transformational action. To translate the Canadian ambitions into actions, human rights must be infused into the Canadian Indicator Framework, and these must be substantive, de facto, rights—rights that people can actually claim, and hold state actors accountable to.Keywords
Funding Information
- Canada Research Chairs
- Social Sciences Humanities Research Council
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- ‘Food is a Right … Nobody Should Be Starving on Our Streets’: Perceptions of Food Bank Usage in a Mid-Sized City in Ontario, CanadaJournal of Human Rights Practice, 2017
- Realising our (neoliberal) potential? A critical discourse analysis of the Poverty Reduction Strategy in Ontario, CanadaCritical Social Policy, 2016
- Accountability for the Sustainable Development Goals: A Lost Opportunity?Ethics & International Affairs, 2016
- No right to food and nutrition in the SDGs: mistake or success?BMJ Global Health, 2016
- Assessing the sustainable development goals from a human rights perspectiveJournal of International and Comparative Social Policy, 2016
- Introduction: Language Policy and Political Economy2015
- From Millennium Development Goals to Sustainable Development GoalsThe Lancet, 2012
- Barriers to addressing the social determinants of health: Insights from the Canadian experienceHealth Policy, 2008
- The Human Right to Access Clean EnergyJournal of Green Building, 2008
- Social determinants of health inequalitiesThe Lancet, 2005