With or Without a Script? Comparing Two Styles of Participatory Video on Enhancing Local Seed Innovation System in Bangladesh
- 1 December 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Journal of Agricultural Education and Extension
- Vol. 16 (4) , 355-371
Abstract
Recent experiences in participatory video-making raise the question of how best to use this medium for enhancing local seed innovation systems. Embedded in a mini-process of participatory action research, two styles of participatory video—scripted and scriptless—were tested and assessed together with farmers and facilitators in Bogra District, Bangladesh. Data, collected through participant observation, informal interviews, group discussions and workshops, were analysed using a combination of Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) and Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats (SWOT) analysis. Scripted video can be used as a capacity-building tool and for disseminating sustainable technologies or local knowledge across geographical scales. But there is a risk of goal orientation to produce quality films, which may undermine the spirit of participation and ownership of the process. In the scriptless style, the process seems to be more inclusive but random, and hence, less goal-oriented. Scriptless video can be used as a monitoring tool in local seed innovation systems. Moreover, potential for stimulating self-sustaining spirit within the participant actors appeared to be higher in this style. However, this style may be difficult to institutionalize. Because of the spontaneous and subjective nature of the process and outcome (i.e. the film) that underlies scriptless videos, participatory video may be produced in a specific geographical context and not necessarily be replicable or relevant elsewhere. This study raises several critiques about the usefulness of these two major styles of participatory video and argues that both styles have specific usefulness and therefore can be used in combination to enhance local seed innovation systems in Bangladesh, and possibly, elsewhere in South Asia.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- The promise of positive deviants: bridging divides between scientific research and local practices in smallholder agricultureKnowledge Management for Development Journal, 2009
- Multiple Approaches to Enhance Communication Between Rice Farmers, Rural Service Providers and ScientistsOutlooks on Pest Management, 2008
- Assessing the suitability of community-based management for the Nyungwe Forest Reserve, RwandaForest Policy and Economics, 2006
- Zooming-in zooming-out: a novel method to scale up local innovations and sustainable technologiesInternational Journal of Agricultural Sustainability, 2006
- Communication for Rural Innovation2004
- Utilizing the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) in SWOT analysis — a hybrid method and its application to a forest-certification caseForest Policy and Economics, 2000
- Using Video for Research and Representation: basic human needs and critical pedagogyJournal of Educational Media, 1999
- Video for recording and training in participatory developmentDevelopment in Practice, 1998
- Local seed systems and their importance for an improved seed supply in developing countriesEuphytica, 1994