Spectroscopic QSAR Methods and Self-Organizing Molecular Field Analysis for Relating Molecular Structure and Estrogenic Activity
Authors:
- 28 October 2003
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in Journal of Chemical Information and Computer Sciences
- Vol. 43 (6) , 1974-1981
Abstract
The performance of three "spectroscopic" quantitative structure-activity relationship (QSAR) methods (eigenvalue (EVA), electronic eigenvalue (EEVA), and comparative spectra analysis (CoSA)) for relating molecular structure and estrogenic activity are critically evaluated. The methods were tested with respect to the relative binding affinities (RBA) of a diverse set of 36 estrogens previously examined in detail by the comparative molecular field analysis method. The CoSA method with (13)C chemical shifts appears to provide a predictive QSAR model for this data set. EEVA (i.e., molecular orbital energy in this context) is a borderline case, whereas the performances of EVA (i.e., vibrational normal mode) and CoSA with (1)H shifts are substandard and only semiquantitative. The CoSA method with (13)C chemical shifts provides an alternative and supplement to conventional 3D QSAR methods for rationalizing and predicting the estrogenic activity of molecules. If CoSA is to be applied to large data sets, however, it is desirable that the chemical shifts are available from common databases or, alternatively, that they can be estimated with sufficient accuracy using fast prediction schemes. Calculations of NMR chemical shifts by quantum mechanical methods, as in this case study, seem to be too time-consuming at this moment, but the situation is changing rapidly. An inherent shortcoming common to all spectroscopic QSAR methods is that they cannot take the chirality of molecules into account, at least as formulated at present. Moreover, the symmetry of molecules may cause additional problems. There are three pairs of enantiomers and nine symmetric (C(2) or C(2)(v)) molecules present in the data set, so that the predictive ability of full 3D QSAR methods is expected to be better than that of spectroscopic methods. This is demonstrated with SOMFA (self-organizing molecular field analysis). In general, the use of external test sets with randomized data is encouraged as a validation tool in QSAR studies.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Decision Forest: Combining the Predictions of Multiple Independent Decision Tree ModelsJournal of Chemical Information and Computer Sciences, 2003
- QSAR Modeling Using Chirality Descriptors Derived from Molecular TopologyJournal of Chemical Information and Computer Sciences, 2002
- Comparative Structural Connectivity Spectra Analysis (CoSCoSA) Models of Steroid Binding to the Corticosteroid Binding GlobulinJournal of Chemical Information and Computer Sciences, 2002
- 13C NMR and Electron Ionization Mass Spectrometric Data-Activity Relationship Model of Estrogen Receptor BindingToxicology and Applied Pharmacology, 2000
- Producing 13C NMR, Infrared Absorption, and Electron Ionization Mass Spectrometric Data Models of the Monodechlorination of Chlorobenzenes, Chlorophenols, and ChloroanilinesJournal of Chemical Information and Computer Sciences, 2000
- The EVA spectral descriptorEuropean Journal of Medicinal Chemistry, 2000
- Novel Variable Selection Quantitative Structure−Property Relationship Approach Based on thek-Nearest-Neighbor PrincipleJournal of Chemical Information and Computer Sciences, 1999
- EEVA (Electronic Eigenvalue): A New QSAR/QSPR Descriptor for Electronic Substituent Effects Based on Molecular Orbital EnergiesSAR and QSAR in Environmental Research, 1999
- A Testing Deadline for Endocrine Disrupters: Testing for Fetal effectsEnvironmental Science & Technology, 1996
- Efficient implementation of the gauge-independent atomic orbital method for NMR chemical shift calculationsJournal of the American Chemical Society, 1990