A Comparison of Predictive Outcomes of APACHE II and SAPS II in a Surgical Intensive Care Unit
Authors:
- 3 September 2001
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in American Journal of Medical Quality
- Vol. 16 (5) , 161-165
Abstract
The Acute Physiologic Score and Chronic Health Evaluation (APACHE) II and the Simplified Acute Physiologic Scale (SAPS) II are two of the more commonly employed predictors of outcome and performance in the intensive care unit setting. However, controversy persists about whether the scores generated by these systems have similar predictive value. This study compared the predicted mortalities derived from APACHE II and SAPS II and contrasted them to the actual mortality in a surgical intensive care unit (SICU). Data for 1665 patients admitted to the SICU between July 1994 and August 1997 were entered into an SICU computerized database. From recorded demographic, hemodynamic, and laboratory data, APACHE II and SAPS II scores were obtained with corresponding predicted mortalities. Patients were stratified by age into categories of less than and greater than 65 years old. Predicted mortalities by APACHE II and SAPS II were compared for each group. An additional analysis included a comparison of survivors and nonsurvivors. There was no significant difference in predicted mortality between APACHE II and SAPS II in any of the groups. Actual mortality was 30 of 486 (6.2%) in patients less than 65 years of age and 73 of 1179 (6.2%) in patients 65 years of age or greater. The APACHE II and SAPS LI predicted mortalities (mean ± SD) for patients less than 65 years of age were 10.5% ± 10.6% and 10.9% ± 13.3%, respectively (P> .05). The APACHE II and SAPS II predicted mortalities in patients 65 years of age or greater were 19.1% ± 17.8% and 18.7% ± 21.0%, respectively (P> .05). Similarly, when patients were stratified by survival status, no significant difference was present between groups. However, in individual patients, a difference between APACHE II and SAPS II scores was often present. We conclude that although disparities between APACHE II and SAPS II predicted mortalities in individual patients may be significant, APACHE II and SAPS II have similar predictive value in a large SICU patient population. However, both APACHE II and SAPS II systems overestimate mortality in SICU patients. Based on our results, we conclude that either system can be used to measure quality of care in the SICU; however, neither system can be reliably applied to a single patient.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- ICU SCORING SYSTEMS DO NOT ALLOW PREDICTION OF PATIENT OUTCOMES OR COMPARISON OF ICU PERFORMANCECritical Care Clinics, 1996
- Predicting Intensive Care Unit Outcome with Scoring Systems: Underlying Concepts and PrinciplesCritical Care Clinics, 1994
- Statistical Approaches to Development and Validation of Predictive InstrumentsCritical Care Clinics, 1994
- A New Simplified Acute Physiology Score (SAPS II) Based on a European/North American Multicenter StudyJAMA, 1993
- Comparison of APACHE II, TRISS, and a Proposed 24-Hour ICU Point System for Prediction of Outcome in ICU Trauma Patients1992
- The APACHE III Prognostic SystemChest, 1991
- APACHE IICritical Care Medicine, 1985
- A simplified acute physiology score for ICU patientsCritical Care Medicine, 1984
- Use of physiologic monitoring to predict outcome and to assist in clinical decisions in critically ill postoperative patientsThe American Journal of Surgery, 1983
- APACHE—acute physiology and chronic health evaluation: a physiologically based classification systemCritical Care Medicine, 1981