Exploring the Politics of Blame: School inspection and its contestation in New Zealand and England
Author:
- 28 June 1998
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Comparative Education
- Vol. 34 (2) , 195-209
Abstract
This article examines how New Zealand's Education Review Office (ERO) and England's Office for Standards in Education (OFSTED) attempt to construct school failure as the clear responsibility of schools in order to gain ideological power as agents of accountability. These 'politics of blame' are contested in both settings by an alternative 'contextual' claim which seeks to take account of broader social and political constraints on schools. It is argued that whereas New Zealand academics have been distrustful of the ERO's agenda, English school effectiveness and school improvement researchers have often provided support for OFSTED's politics of blame. However this relationship represents a double-edged sword for OFSTED because some school effectiveness/school improvement researchers also partly support the contextual claim. The article concludes that the politics of blame and their contestation will continue to be important in these settings and elsewhere.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Giving the 'Hidden Hand' a Helping Hand? The rhetoric and reality of neoliberal education reform in England and New ZealandComparative Education, 1997
- HMI and OFSTED : Evolution or Revolution in School InspectionBritish Journal of Educational Studies, 1997
- A Bit of a Curate's Egg? Three Decades of Official Thinking About the Quality of SchoolsBritish Journal of Educational Studies, 1997
- Teachers' Intention to Change Practice as a Result of Ofsted School InspectionsEducational Management & Administration, 1996
- Sociology of Education, State Schooling and Social Class: beyond critiques of the New Right hegemonyBritish Journal of Sociology of Education, 1996
- Teachers’ Perceptions of School Inspection: a stressful experienceCambridge Journal of Education, 1995
- Educational reform and the contradictory discourses of evaluationEvaluation & Research in Education, 1994
- The Sociology of School EffectivenessBritish Journal of Sociology of Education, 1993
- Democracy and the effective schools movement in New ZealandInternational Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 1988
- HMI's interpretations of schools’ examination resultsJournal of Education Policy, 1986