Individual and Shared Components of Conversational Enjoyment: The Role of Demographics and Personality
Preprint
- 5 June 2026
- preprint
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Abstract
Post-conversation evaluations are partly shared between partners and partly specific to each individual. Using a mixed-effects actor-partner interdependence (APIM) framework, we analyzed 1,602 first-encounter conversations, modeling a composite of enjoyment, liking, and perceived conversational skill. Variance in post-conversation positivity was distributed across stable perceiver tendencies (17.4%), stable target tendencies (19.9%), a shared conversation-level component (18.5%), and residual variation (44.2%). Partners showed modest within-dyad similarity (label-invariant ICC = .201), while absolute within-dyad gaps averaged nearly one standard deviation (mean |D| = 0.93). Personality traits and demographics jointly accounted for 9.0% of variance in positivity and 5.3% of the directional asymmetry between partners’ ratings. Agreeableness, Openness, and age were associated primarily with more positive perceiver-side evaluations, whereas Extraversion, female sex, and higher educational attainment were associated more strongly with partner-rated positivity. At the dyad level, fixed effects accounted for 11.1% of between-dyad variation in dyadic mean positivity and reproduced 24.0% of the observed cross-partner covariance. A descriptive label-invariant covariance decomposition further suggested that the modest within-dyad covariance attributable to measured characteristics arose mainly from additive perceiver-target structure rather than assortative pairing. The same predictors, however, did not capture the magnitude of within-dyad disagreement: predicted gaps were uniformly small while observed gaps varied widely. Stable individual differences therefore mattered in two ways, both as a lens through which conversations were evaluated and as part of the impression left on partners, while much of dyadic gap size remained unexplained by the measured stable characteristics.Keywords
All Related Versions
Funding Information
- Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo (#2023/11070-1, #2024/06797- 2, #22/05848-7)
- Vetenskapsrådet (#2020-03812)
- Norges Forskningsråd (#343370)