Assessing effectiveness of home care for persons with AIDS: Analysis of methodological problems
- 1 October 2002
- journal article
- clinical trial
- Published by Taylor & Francis in AIDS Care
- Vol. 14 (5) , 645-650
Abstract
The aim of this paper is to assess the methodological problems of an unsuccessful randomized controlled trial (RCT) conducted to evaluate the effectiveness, in terms of survival and quality of life, of the early offer of home care (HC) to persons with AIDS (PWA). The study carried out was an intention-to-treat RCT. Persons in the treatment group (TG) received the offer of HC at the moment of AIDS diagnosis; those in the control group (CG) received it six months from diagnosis. Many problems have hindered the progress of the study: particularly, the low compliance to the offer and the failure to enroll the required sample size have made the results unreliable. Analogous problems have been reported within other trials evaluating HC in different fields. The present study thoroughly evaluates the specific ethical and methodological problems encountered in designing and conducting a RCT on HC for PWA. We conclude that, before designing and conducting a RCT in this field, it is advisable to examine some main issues carefully, such as the acceptability of the offer of treatment, the expected compliance and the required size of the study population. If one or more of these elements prove to be problematic, the results of the trial risk being seriously compromised, and alternative approaches should be considered.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- ADJUSTING FOR NON-COMPLIANCE AND CONTAMINATION IN RANDOMIZED CLINICAL TRIALSStatistics in Medicine, 1997
- Heterogeneity of home care assistance needs of people with AIDSAIDS Care, 1997
- Meeting the Service Needs of HIV-Infected Persons: Is the Ryan White CARE Act Succeeding?JAIDS Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes, 1997
- Methods of Randomized Controlled Clinical Trials in Health Services ResearchMedical Care, 1995
- Need for rigorous assessment of palliative careBMJ, 1994
- Evaluation of a palliative care service: problems and pitfallsBMJ, 1994
- Specialized home care for patients with AIDS: an experiment in Rotterdam, The NetherlandsJournal of Advanced Nursing, 1994
- Care requirements of people with ARC/AIDS in Rome: Non-hospital servicesAIDS Care, 1994
- Randomised controlled trial of effects of coordinating care for terminally ill cancer patients.BMJ, 1992
- A Health Status Questionnaire Using 30 Items From The Medical Outcomes StudyMedical Care, 1991