Different biology but shared distribution: genetic structure of two common starfish

Authors:
  • PCPalacín Creu
    Palacín Creu
  • VRVentura Renato
    Ventura Renato
  • PPPaiva Paulo
    Paiva Paulo
  • FBFeital Barbara
    Feital Barbara
  • KYKhadra Yousra
    Khadra Yousra
  • PRPérez-Portela Rocío
    Pérez-Portela Rocío

Abstract
In the Mediterranean Sea, 154 echinoderm species have been recorded, of which 33 are starfish. Life-history traits of each species determine the specific genetic structure of their populations. Reproductive strategies and larval or adult dispersal play important roles on population connectivity and genetic diversity in marine benthic species. Other factors also contribute to shape this structure: ocean circulation, population size or stochastic factors during larval recruitment are only some examples. Echinaster sepositus and Coscinasterias tenuispina are two common starfish on the rocky bottoms of the Mediterranean and temperate Atlantic, living between 0 and 200 m. Both species have a shared distribution range, despite their different biological characteristics. E. sepositus reproduces only by sexual reproduction and produces lecithotrophic larvae that cannot feed in the water column, and therefore have low dispersal potential. In contrast, C. tenuispina is able to reproduce asexually by fission and sexually producing planktotrophic larvae with a theoretically high dispersal potential. Thus, both species may be expected to present different genetic patterns: a marked structure in the case of E. sepositus, and high population connectivity, in the case of C. tenuispina. A total of 320 individuals from over 15 different localities were sampled, sequenced and genotyped for each species. We analysed a region of the Cytochrome oxidase subunit 1 (COI) and microsatellite loci from both species. Both starfish presented the lowest haplotype and nucleotide diversity of all echinoderms previously studied along the Mediterranean. Nevertheless, E. sepositus showed homogeneous diversity values within the different studied basins, with maximum values in western Mediterranean. C. tenuispina presented remarkably higher diversity in the Canary Islands and differences among localities within the western Mediterranean. The reasons for these low diversity values can be linked to their biology: a recent demographic expansion from few alleles could explain the low diversity in E. sepositus, while the presence of clonality processes could explain the diversity patterns of C. tenuispina, due to differences in sexual to asexual ratio between localities. Population connectivity of both species along their distribution ranges were limited by different marine barriers, such as the Almería-Oran front or the Siculo-Tunisian strait, that prevent gene flow. Moreover, despite the low dispersal potential of the E. sepositus larvae, this species presented little genetic structure between populations throughout the different basins, reinforcing the hypothesis that other factors than larval dispersal influence the genetic structure. Conversely, the large dispersal potential of larvae does not fully explain the genetic structure in C. tenuispina, which is influenced by asexual reproduction. The presence of the same clone in distant localities would be explained by adult dispersal, whereas the presence of different genotypes of the species at both sides of the Atlantic can be explained by the large dispersal capacity of the larvae.