Reported methodological quality of split‐mouth studies
Authors:
- Emmanuel LesaffreELEmmanuel Lesaffre
- Ian NeedlemanINIan Needleman
- On Behalf Of The Iscb Subcommittee On DentistryODOn Behalf Of The Iscb Subcommittee On Dentistry
- 16 August 2007
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Clinical Periodontology
- Vol. 34 (9) , 756-761
Abstract
Background/Aim: Hujoel & Moulton previously questioned the reported quality of split‐mouth studies. Since then, there has been little enquiry into the methodology of this study design. The aim was to conduct a systematic review of the reported methodology of clinical studies using a split‐mouth design published in dental journals over a 1‐year period (2004).Material and Methods: An extension of the CONSORT guidelines for cluster‐randomized designs was used to evaluate quality. We evaluated the methods used and quality of reporting split‐mouth studies.Results: Thirty‐four studies were eligible for this review. The results showed that many papers lack essential qualities of good reporting, e.g. five of 34 papers gave the rationale for choosing a split‐mouth design, 19 of 34 (56%) used appropriate analytical statistical methods and only one of 34 presented an appropriate sample size calculation. Of the five studies that used survival analysis, none of them used a paired approach.Conclusions: Despite some progress in statistical analysis, if the reporting of studies represents the actual methodology of the trial, this review has identified important aspects of split‐mouth study design and analysis that would benefit from development.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- CONSORT statement: extension to cluster randomised trialsBMJ, 2004
- Quality of RCTs in Periodontology— A Systematic ReviewJournal of Dental Research, 2002
- A survey of endpoint characteristics in periodontal clinical trials published 1988–1992, and implications for future studiesJournal of Clinical Periodontology, 1995
- Empirical Evidence of BiasJAMA, 1995
- Empirical evidence of bias. Dimensions of methodological quality associated with estimates of treatment effects in controlled trialsJAMA, 1995
- Validity issues in split‐mouth trials*Journal of Clinical Periodontology, 1992
- Efficiency of split‐mouth designsJournal of Clinical Periodontology, 1990
- Evaluation of test statistics in split‐mouth clinical trialsJournal of Periodontal Research, 1988
- A Generalized Gehan and Gilbert Test for Paired Observations that are Subject to Arbitrary Right CensorshipJournal of the American Statistical Association, 1980
- A Generalized Gehan and Gilbert Test for Paired Observations that are Subject to Arbitrary Right CensorshipJournal of the American Statistical Association, 1980