Does Auditor Reputation Matter? The Case of KPMG Germany and ComROAD AG
Authors:
- Jieying ZhangJZJieying Zhang
- 23 July 2008
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Accounting Research
- Vol. 46 (4) , 941-972
Abstract
We study the stock and audit market effects associated with a widely publicized accounting scandal involving a public company (ComROAD AG) and a large, reputable audit firm (KPMG) in a country (Germany) that has long provided auditors with substantial protection from shareholder legal liability. We use this event to study whether an auditor's reputation helps to ensure audit quality, a rationale for which recent literature and events provide scant support. Given the absence of a strong insurance rationale for audit quality, Germany permits a relatively clean test of whether auditor reputation matters. We find that KPMG's clients sustain negative abnormal returns of 3% at events pertaining to ComROAD, and that these returns are more negative for companies that are likely to have higher demands for audit quality. We also find an increase in the number of clients that drop KPMG in the year of the ComROAD scandal (mostly smaller, recently public companies that are similar to ComROAD). Overall, our results provide support for the reputation rationale for audit quality.Keywords
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- Who Cares about Auditor Reputation?*Contemporary Accounting Research, 2005
- IAS Versus U.S. GAAP: Information Asymmetry–Based Evidence from Germany's New MarketJournal of Accounting Research, 2003
- IAS Versus U.S. GAAP: Information Asymmetry–Based Evidence from Germany's New MarketJournal of Accounting Research, 2003
- The Impact of the European Union Insurance Directives on Insurance Company StocksJournal of Risk and Insurance, 2003
- Why Do Audits Fail? Evidence from Lincoln Savings and LoanJournal of Accounting Research, 2000
- Audit Quality and Auditor Size: An Evaluation of Reputation and Deep Pockets HypothesesJournal of Business Finance & Accounting, 1999
- Client Security Price Reactions to the Laventhol and Horwath BankruptcyJournal of Accounting Research, 1995
- An Approach to Statistical Inference in Cross-Sectional Models with Security Abnormal Returns As Dependent VariableJournal of Accounting Research, 1986
- Reputation and Product QualityThe Bell Journal of Economics, 1983
- A Heteroskedasticity-Consistent Covariance Matrix Estimator and a Direct Test for HeteroskedasticityEconometrica, 1980