Schemes for Allocation of Benefits from Contracted Water-Saving: The Case of Irrigated Field Projects in China
Authors:
- 22 September 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by World Scientific Pub Co Pte Ltd in Water Economics and Policy
- Vol. 09 (04)
Abstract
The shortage of water resources has seriously restricted the sustainable development of China’s economy. Contracted water-saving management (WSMC) has emerged as an important measure to effectively alleviate this problem. However, the rationality and fairness of benefit allocation affect the stakeholders’ enthusiasm for participating in the project. The lack of a water-saving benefit allocation scheme is one of the critical obstacles hindering the implementation and promotion of the project. This study identifies the core stakeholders in WSMC projects in Field-project in an irrigation district. Then, with comprehensive consideration of the importance, cost input, risk-taking, and effort of each participant, we examined the benefit allocation scheme in the WSMC projects of Field-project in an irrigation district by building a model based on Nash Equilibrium, Shapley value method, and modified Shapley value method. We found that the case in which the WUA E implements the WSMC project alone yields the lowest total revenue of the schemes considered, and each participant’s benefit is also at the lowest. Nash Equilibrium can achieve the maximum expected return for both participants. With the Shapley value method, the WUA E earns the largest benefits, accounting for 57.5% of total revenue, followed by the WSSE D. Under the calculation principle of the modified Shapley value model, the WUA E’s benefit decreases significantly, implying that the revenues previously earned by the WUA E are transferred to the WSSE D. This result is due to the below-average levels of importance, cost input risk-taking, and effort for WUA E in the project. It can be seen that the modified Shapley value method is more suitable for benefit allocation of the WSMC project of Field-project in an irrigation district. Finally, a typical case study in China on a shared WSMC project of Field-project in an irrigation district showed how the proposed method works. Then, we proposed policy implications for promoting project implementation from three perspectives: stakeholders, income distribution, and risk management, and identified the limitations of the research and outlined the future research directions.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Natural Science Foundation of China (71774132)
- Shaanxi Water Conservancy Science and Technology Project (2022slkj-1)
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Compatibility of interval fuzzy preference relations with the COWA operator and its application to group decision makingSoft Computing, 2013
- Probabilistic risk assessment of the energy saving shortfall in energy performance contracting projects–A case studyEnergy and Buildings, 2013
- Engineering Risk Management Planning in Energy Performance Contracting in ChinaSystems Engineering Procedia, 2011
- Energy service companies to improve energy efficiency in China: barriers and removal measuresProcedia Earth and Planetary Science, 2009
- The economics of energy service contractsEnergy Policy, 2007
- Force Majeure in Project FinanceThe Journal of Structured Finance, 2006
- From volatility to value: analysing and managing financial and performance risk in energy savings projectsEnergy Policy, 2006
- Risk analysis and management in constructionInternational Journal of Project Management, 1997
- Families of OWA operatorsFuzzy Sets and Systems, 1993
- AN INDEX FOR MEASURING THE PERFORMANCE OF IRRIGATION MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS WITH AN APPLICATION1Jawra Journal of the American Water Resources Association, 1988