University vs. Research Institute? The Dual Pillars of German Science Production, 1950–2010
Open Access
- 7 February 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Minerva
- Vol. 58 (3) , 319-342
Abstract
The world’s third largest producer of scientific research, Germany, is the origin of the research university and the independent, extra-university research institute. Its dual-pillar research policy differentiates these organizational forms functionally: universities specialize in advanced research-based teaching; institutes specialize intensely on research. Over the past decades this policy affected each sector differently: while universities suffered a lingering “legitimation crisis,” institutes enjoyed deepening “favored sponsorship”—financial and reputational advantages. Universities led the nation’s reestablishment of scientific prominence among the highly competitive European and global science systems after WWII. But sectoral analysis of contributions to science, technology, engineering, mathematics, and medical and health journal publications (1950–2010) finds that Germany’s small to medium-sized independent research institutes have made significant, growing contributions, particularly in publishing in higher impact journals proportionally more than their size. Simultaneously—despite dual-pillar policy implications—the university sector continues to be absolutely and relatively successful; not eclipsed by the institutes. Universities have consistently produced two-thirds of the nation’s publications in the highest quality journals since at least 1980 and have increased publications at a logarithmic rate; higher than the international mean. Indeed, they led Germany into the global mega-science style of production. Contrary to assumed benefits of functional differentiation, our results indicate that relative to their size, each sector has produced approximately similar publication records. While institutes have succeeded, the larger university sector, despite much less funding growth, has remained fundamental to German science production. Considering these findings, we discuss the future utility of the dual-pillar policy.Keywords
Funding Information
- Qatar National Research Fund (NPRP Grant No. 5-1021-5-159)
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- The influences of counting methods on university rankings based on paper count and citation countJournal of Informetrics, 2013
- Why New Hybrid Organizations are Formed: Historical Perspectives on Epistemic and Academic DriftMinerva, 2013
- Cooperation with public research institutions and success in innovation: Evidence from France and GermanyResearch Policy, 2013
- Why are higher education participation rates in Germany so low? Institutional barriers to higher education expansionJournal of Education and Work, 2011
- Across institutional boundaries?Research Policy, 2008
- The Research University in Transition: The Emerging Global ModelHigher Education Policy, 2008
- The Institutional Crisis of the German Research UniversityHigher Education Policy, 2008
- Bachelor of What, Master of Whom? The Humboldt Myth and Historical Transformations of Higher Education in German‐Speaking Europe and the US1European Journal of Education, 2006
- Trends in the Restructuring of German UniversitiesComparative Education Review, 2006
- Basic research and industrial enterpriseMinerva, 1984