Some Methodological Problems in Comparative Politics
Author:
- Andrew Murray FaureAFAndrew Murray Faure
- 1 July 1994
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Theoretical Politics
- Vol. 6 (3) , 307-322
Abstract
This article attempts to highlight the logical fabric of comparison in comparative politics. The framework encompassing various views on the nature of comparison includes epistemological notions that underlie comparative analysis such as the contexts of discovery and justification in science, as well as the role of logic within these contexts. These various views on the nature of comparison range from (1) the MSSD (Most Similar Systems Design) to (2) the MDSD (Most Different Systems Design); (3) the possibility of mirror-imagng these designs; (4) the notion that comparison is such an intrinsic part of science that it cannot deserve special status; (5) the notion that comparison is of such divergent nature that it cannot be classified; and (6) the view that comparison should be regarded as a debate over the strategic employment of scientific method. In closing, a general conclusion on the locus and role of methodology in comparative politics is offered.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- On Time and Comparative ResearchJournal of Theoretical Politics, 1993
- Strategy Versus Methodology in Comparative ResearchComparative Political Studies, 1977
- II. The Comparable-Cases Strategy in Comparative ResearchComparative Political Studies, 1975
- I. “Most Different Systems” and “Most Similar Systems”Comparative Political Studies, 1975
- IV. Comparative Research, Experimental Design, and the Comparative MethodComparative Political Studies, 1975
- Comparative Politics and the Comparative MethodAmerican Political Science Review, 1971
- Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge1970
- Comparative Political Analysis in Montesquieu and TocquevilleComparative Politics, 1969
- More on "The Logic of Discovery"The Journal of Philosophy, 1960
- The Logic of DiscoveryThe Journal of Philosophy, 1958