Tourism futures and Working Holiday Maker schemes: a systematic review and scenario analysis
Open Access
- 4 September 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Tourism Futures
- p. 1-21
Abstract
Purpose: This study conducts the first systematic review of Working Holiday Maker (WHM) research to analyse the evolving nature of WHM schemes and participants. It aims to identify existing theoretical and methodological foundations, to reveal gaps in current knowledge and develop future scenarios for WHM programmes in the context of changing tourism, work and migration patterns. Design/methodology/approach: A 2x2 matrix was developed to generate a distinct picture of WHM participants’ motivations and self-perceptions, with axes derived from the review findings. Four corresponding future scenarios were then constructed to explore potential policy and tourism implications. Findings: The analysis revealed a lack of consensus regarding fundamental theoretical frameworks and the social classification of WHMs, highlighting a dominant binary perspective of WHMs as either tourists or temporary migrant workers. The 2x2 matrix demonstrates the inadequacy of traditional tourist–worker dichotomies by revealing four distinct WHM types characterised by motivational fluidity and varying self-perceptions. Practical implications: The study provides a consolidated overview of WHM research and introduces a scenario planning framework with four policy pathways, informing evidence-based policy development for WHM schemes. Social implications: The research contributes to understanding how contemporary mobility patterns challenge traditional assumptions about gap-year experiences, cultural exchange outcomes and temporary-to-permanent migration transitions by revealing motivational fluidity among WHM participants and demonstrating how institutional frameworks actively shape cross-cultural work–travel combinations. Originality/value: This represents the first systematic review of WHM research combined with scenario planning methodology, contributing a novel theoretical framework that challenges existing binary conceptualisations and introduces the first comprehensive synthesis of fragmented interdisciplinary literature.Keywords
This publication has 97 references indexed in Scilit:
- Youth as Temporary Workers Abroad: The Experiences of Australia, Canada and New Zealand2022
- From Working Tourists to Permanent Residents: Experiences of Migrant Workers with Youth Mobility Schemes in CanadaJournal of International Migration and Integration, 2021
- Pacific seasonal workers: Learning from the contrasting temporary migration outcomes in Australian and New Zealand horticultureAsia & the Pacific Policy Studies, 2018
- Theorising new European youth mobilitiesPopulation, Space and Place, 2017
- Labour Market and Economic Impacts of International Working Holiday Temporary Migrants to AustraliaPopulation, Space and Place, 2011
- Intimate encounters: the embodied transnationalism of backpackers and independent travellersPopulation, Space and Place, 2009
- Five backpacker tourist enclavesInternational Journal of Tourism Research, 2007
- Globalization and changes in Australian international migrationJournal of Population Research, 2006
- Mobility, fixity, agency: Australia's working holiday programmePopulation, Space and Place, 2004
- Roles tourists playAnnals of Tourism Research, 1992