Collaboration Derailed: The Politics of “Community-Based” Resource Management in Nevada County
Authors:
- 1 September 2004
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Society & Natural Resources
- Vol. 17 (8) , 735-751
Abstract
Collaborative natural resource management (CNRM) is often portrayed as a way to find “win–win” solutions that move “beyond ” bitter adversarial politics. Research on failures of CNRM emphasizes institutional and procedural barriers. In contrast, using a study of a failed CNRM program in Nevada County, California, we emphasize the role of intracommunity politics. We build on work by Few (2001) Few, R. 2001. Containment and counter-containment: Planner/community relations in conservation planning. Geograph J., 167(Part 2): 111–124. [Crossref] [Google Scholar] that examines political “containment” and “capture” of collaborative processes. In Nevada County, we identify another political tactic: the strategic use of “derailment” of CNRM by powerful interests to achieve goals outside the collaborative process. Expanding upon Amy (1987) Amy, D. 1987. The politics of environmental mediation, New York: Columbia University Press. [Google Scholar] , we suggest that this example illustrates that collaboration is not separate from, or “beyond,” politics. CNRM can become an avenue of power that social groups use to achieve broader political ends. This calls into question the general optimism about CNRM and the current emphasis on making it “work” by refining institutions and procedures.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- “The Intention Was Good”: Legitimacy, Consensus-Based Decision Making, and the Case of Forest Planning in British Columbia, CanadaSociety & Natural Resources, 2004
- Landscape changes in Nevada County reflect social and ecological transitionsCalifornia Agriculture, 2003
- Evaluating Collaborative Natural ResourceManagementSociety & Natural Resources, 2003
- Policy Reviews and EssaysSociety & Natural Resources, 2003
- Social Organization and Participatory Resource Management in Brazilian Ribeirinho Communities: A Case Study of the Mamirauà Sustainable Development Reserve, AmazonasSociety & Natural Resources, 2001
- Containment and counter‐containment: planner/community relations in conservation planningThe Geographical Journal, 2001
- Community Natural Resource Management: Promise, Rhetoric, and RealitySociety & Natural Resources, 2000
- Getting Past Yes: From Capital Creation to ActionJournal of the American Planning Association, 1999
- Collaborative Management of Public Rangeland in Wyoming: Lessons in Co-ManagementThe Professional Geographer, 1998
- Editorial: Community-Based Sustainable Development: Consensus or Conflict?IDS Bulletin, 1997