Open peer review: A randomised controlled trial
Authors:
- Maeve RooneyMRMaeve Rooney
- Louis ApplebyLALouis Appleby
- Greg WilkinsonGWGreg Wilkinson
Top Cited Papers
Open Access
- 2 January 2000
- journal article
- clinical trial
- Published by Royal College of Psychiatrists in The British Journal of Psychiatry
- Vol. 176 (1) , 47-51
Abstract
Background: Most scientific journals practise anonymous peer review. There is no evidence, however, that this is any better than an open system.Aims: To evaluate the feasibility of an open peer review system.Method: Reviewers for the British Journal of Psychiatry were asked whether they would agree to have their name revealed to the authors whose papers they review; 408 manuscripts assigned to reviewers who agreed were randomised to signed or unsigned groups. We measured review quality, tone, recommendation for publication and time taken to complete each review.Results: A total of 245 reviewers (76%) agreed to sign. Signed reviews were of higher quality, were more courteous and took longer to complete than unsigned reviews. Reviewers who signed were more likely to recommend publication.Conclusions: This study supports the feasibility of an open peer review system and identifies such a system's potential drawbacks.Keywords
This publication has 7 references indexed in Scilit:
- Effect of open peer review on quality of reviews and on reviewers'recommendations: a randomised trialBMJ, 1999
- Opening up BMJ peer reviewBMJ, 1999
- Effect on the Quality of Peer Review of Blinding Reviewers and Asking Them to Sign Their ReportsJAMA, 1998
- What Makes a Good Reviewer and a Good Review for a General Medical Journal?JAMA, 1998
- The Ingelfinger ruleThe Lancet, 1996
- The number needed to treat: a clinically useful measure of treatment effectBMJ, 1995
- The Effects of Blinding on the Quality of Peer ReviewJAMA, 1990