European Communities – Measures Affecting the Approval and Marketing of Biotech Products
Authors:
- 1 January 2009
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in World Trade Review
- Vol. 8 (1) , 49-83
Abstract
TheEC-Biotechdispute exposed the WTO dispute settlement system to a more challenging test than any previous dispute. Not only did the Panel have to take a stand on the limits of science, or technocratic regulatory controls, to protect against objective risk, but in this regard faced more complex issues than ever addressed before by an adjudicating body. The dispute also concerned an extremely charged political issue, partly because of inherent ethical sensitivities with regard to foodstuffs, partly due to public skepticism about the role of science, and partly due to a common public perception of the complaint as being driven by the interests of an untrustworthy industry. Because of these and other challenges, the Panel faced an almost impossible task. This paper discusses how the Panel addressed some of these issues. The recently (after our report was drafted) decided appeal inEC–Hormones Suspensionis likely to reduce the significance for WTO jurisprudence of some of the Panel's findings inEC–Biotech, given the apparently different approach of the AB to fundamental interpretative issues under SPS concerning the meaning of risk assessment and precaution.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- Regulatory Purpose and “Like Products” in Article III:4 of the GATT (with Additional Remarks on Article III:2)2006
- The WTO Impact on Internal Regulations: A Case Study of the Canada–EC Asbestos Dispute2006
- The Regulation of International Trade2005
- Environmental Risk, Precaution, and Scientific Rationality in the Context of WTO/NAFTA Trade RulesRisk Analysis, 2004
- Still Hazy after All These Years: The Interpretation of National Treatment in the GATT/WTO Case-law on Tax DiscriminationEuropean Journal of International Law, 2004
- Conflict of Norms in Public International Law2003
- Democracy, Science, and Free Trade: Risk Regulation on Trial at the World Trade OrganizationMichigan Law Review, 2000
- The product/process distinction - an illusory basis for disciplining 'unilateralism' in trade policyEuropean Journal of International Law, 2000