Cricopharyngeal dysfunction: A systematic review comparing outcomes of dilatation, botulinum toxin injection, and myotomy
Authors:
- 11 September 2015
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in The Laryngoscope
- Vol. 126 (1) , 135-141
Abstract
Objectives: Cricopharyngeal dysfunction may lead to severe dysphagia and aspiration. The objective of this systematic review was to evaluate the existing studies on the effectiveness of myotomy, dilatation, and botulinum toxin (BoT) injection in the management of cricopharyngeal dysphagia.Methods: PubMed and Web of Science databases were searched to identify eligible studies by using the terms “cricopharyngeal dysfunction,” “cricopharyngeal myotomy,” “cricopharyngeal botox,” “cricopharyngeal dilation,” and their combinations from 1990 to 2013. This was supplemented by hand‐searching relevant articles. Eligible articles were independently assessed for quality by two authors. Statistical analysis was performed.Results: The database search revealed 567 articles. Thirty‐two articles met eligibility criteria and were further evaluated. The reported success rates of BoT injections was between 43% and 100% (mean = 76%), dilation 58% and 100% (mean = 81%), and myotomy 25% and 100% (mean = 75%). In logistic regression analysis of the patient‐weighted averages, the 78% success rate with myotomy was significantly higher than the 69% success rate with BoT injections (P = .042), whereas the intermediate success rate of 73% with dilation was not significantly different from that of either myotomy (P = .37) or BoT (P = .42). There was a statistically significant difference between endoscopic and open myotomy success rates (P = .0025). Endoscopic myotomy had a higher success rate, with a 2.2 odds ratio.Conclusions: The success rate of myotomy is significantly higher than the success rate of BoT injections in cricopharyngeal dysfunction. Moreover, endoscopic myotomy was found to have a higher success rate compared to open myotomy.Level of Evidence: NALaryngoscope, 126:135–141, 2016Keywords
This publication has 44 references indexed in Scilit:
- Efficacy of large-diameter dilatation in cricopharyngeal dysfunctionThe Laryngoscope, 2011
- Long-Term Results of External Upper Esophageal Sphincter Myotomy for Oropharyngeal DysphagiaDysphagia, 2009
- An electrophysiological approach to the diagnosis of neurogenic dysphagia: implications for botulinum toxin treatmentJournal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry, 2009
- Botulinum Toxin Injection for DysphagiaAmerican Journal of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation, 2009
- Long-lasting effect of a single botulinum toxin injection in the treatment of oropharyngeal dysphagia secondary to upper esophageal sphincter dysfunction: A pilot studyScandinavian Journal of Gastroenterology, 2008
- The role of botulinum toxin injection and upper esophageal sphincter myotomy in treating oropharyngeal dysphagiaJournal of Gastrointestinal Surgery, 2004
- Efficacy of Botulinum Toxin A for Treatment of Upper Esophageal Sphincter DysfunctionThe Laryngoscope, 2000
- Pharyngeal Swallowing DisordersAnnals of Surgery, 1998
- An Experimental Manometric Study Simulating Upper Esophageal Sphincter NarrowingInvestigative Radiology, 1994
- PARALYSIS OF DEGLUTITION, A POST-POLIOMYELITIS COMPLICATION TREATED BY SECTION OF THE CRICOPHARYNGEUS MUSCLE*Annals of Surgery, 1951