RE: "POPULATION- AND COMMUNITY-BASED RECRUITMENT OF AFRICAN AMERICANS AND LATINOS: THE SAN FRANCISCO BAY AREA LUNG CANCER STUDY"

Authors:
  • CAChristine B. Ambrosone
    Christine B. Ambrosone
  • LJLina Jandorf
    Lina Jandorf
  • HFHelena Furberg
    Helena Furberg
  • JBJulie A. Britton
    Julie A. Britton
  • DBDana H. Bovbjerg
    Dana H. Bovbjerg
  • DEDeborah O. Erwin
    Deborah O. Erwin

Abstract
The recent Journal paper by Cabral et al. (1) addresses an epidemiologic issue of paramount importance in the conduct of case-control studies. With falling rates of participation in research, determination of a proper control group, as well as approaches to encouraging full participation by all those who are eligible, will greatly impact the future utility of such studies. In their paper, the authors report that, while recruitment by random digit dialing of African Americans was much more successful than use of Health Care Financing Administration lists (63 percent vs. 19 percent), identification of controls through community-based approaches resulted in the highest participation rates (82 percent). However, it was not possible to calculate an actual denominator for the number of persons contacted. Community-based approaches clearly resulted in better response rates in this study, but it is unclear whether these sources of controls (churches, health fair attendees, senior centers, university employees, and physician practices) are representative of the populations from which the cases arose and will be subject to sampling bias. The authors concluded that “much work is still needed in future studies to determine optimal and valid recruitment methods for minorities” (1, p. 277).