The Battle for Filter Supremacy: A Comparative Study of the Multi-State Constraint Kalman Filter and the Sliding Window Filter
Authors:
- Lee E ClementLCLee E Clement
- Valentin PeretroukhinVPValentin Peretroukhin
- Jacob LambertJLJacob Lambert
- Jonathan KellyJKJonathan Kelly
- 1 June 2015
- conference paper
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 23-30
Abstract
Accurate and consistent ego motion estimation is a critical component of autonomous navigation. For this task, the combination of visual and inertial sensors is an inexpensive, compact, and complementary hardware suite that can be used on many types of vehicles. In this work, we compare two modern approaches to ego motion estimation: the Multi-State Constraint Kalman Filter (MSCKF) and the Sliding Window Filter (SWF). Both filters use an Inertial Measurement Unit (IMU) to estimate the motion of a vehicle and then correct this estimate with observations of salient features from a monocular camera. While the SWF estimates feature positions as part of the filter state itself, the MSCKF optimizes feature positions in a separate procedure without including them in the filter state. We present experimental characterizations and comparisons of the MSCKF and SWF on data from a moving hand-held sensor rig, as well as several traverses from the KITTI dataset. In particular, we compare the accuracy and consistency of the two filters, and analyze the effect of feature track length and feature density on the performance of each filter. In general, our results show the SWF to be more accurate and less sensitive to tuning parameters than the MSCKF. However, the MSCKF is computationally cheaper, has good consistency properties, and improves in accuracy as more features are tracked.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Vision meets robotics: The KITTI datasetThe International Journal of Robotics Research, 2013
- High-precision, consistent EKF-based visual-inertial odometryThe International Journal of Robotics Research, 2013
- Sliding window filter with application to planetary landingJournal of Field Robotics, 2010
- Observability-based Rules for Designing Consistent EKF SLAM EstimatorsThe International Journal of Robotics Research, 2009
- Speeded-Up Robust Features (SURF)Computer Vision and Image Understanding, 2008
- Real-time implementation of airborne inertial-SLAMRobotics and Autonomous Systems, 2007
- Motion Estimation from Image and Inertial MeasurementsThe International Journal of Robotics Research, 2004
- Robust computation and parametrization of multiple view relations2002
- Fusion of vision and gyro tracking for robust augmented reality registration2002
- Bundle Adjustment — A Modern Synthesis2000