Comparing the intensity of scrutiny for ‘domestic’ and implementing bills: does transposition of EU law reduce political contestation in national parliaments?
Author:
- 17 May 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of European Public Policy
- Vol. 24 (7) , 969-988
Abstract
Research on the role of national parliaments in European Union (EU) matters dominantly concentrates on ex ante scrutiny and mostly neglects that many parliaments are constitutionally obliged to play an important part in the implementation of EU law into domestic legal orders. The low interest is tied to an argument that even if national parliaments are involved in transposition, they only serve as constrained agents of the EU. This article tests this assumption and inquires whether there are differences between parliaments’ scrutiny of bills (laws) transposing EU impulses and ‘purely domestic’ bills. Analysis is based on quantitative data from the Czech Chamber of Deputies and the Slovak National Council. While the project remains essentially exploratory, results suggest that while the implementing bills are debated considerably less than the domestic bills, for the remaining included indicators the intensity of scrutiny for the former group of bills on average does not differ from the latter group. The findings might therefore challenge the thesis that that the implementation process is mere formality that consequently reduces political contestation in the legislatures.Keywords
Funding Information
- Czech Grant Agency (13-15422P)
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- Domestic scrutiny of European Union politics: Between whistle blowing and opposition controlEuropean Journal of Political Research, 2013
- Legislative Transposition of Directives: Exploring the Other Role of National Parliaments in the European UnionJCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies, 2012
- Measuring party positions in EuropeParty Politics, 2012
- The transposition of European law in EU member states: between process and politicsEuropean Political Science Review, 2010
- How to Measure the Europeanisation of a National Legislature?Scandinavian Political Studies, 2010
- Troubles with Transposition? Explaining Trends in Member-State Notification and the Delayed Transposition of EU DirectivesBritish Journal of Political Science, 2009
- Democratic Accountability and National Parliaments: Redefining the Impact of Parliamentary Scrutiny in EU AffairsEuropean Law Journal, 2007
- Turning Swift Policy-making into Deadlock and DelayEuropean Union Politics, 2006
- Surviving the DeadlineEuropean Union Politics, 2003
- Conclusion: Addressing the democratic deficitThe Journal of Legislative Studies, 1995