Comparative analysis of HEC-HMS and SWAT hydrological models for simulating the streamflow in sub-humid tropical region in India
- 7 June 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Environmental Science and Pollution Research
- Vol. 31 (28) , 41182-41196
Abstract
Assessment of water availability in sub-humid regions is important due to distinct climatic and environmental conditions. In this study, Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) and Hydrologic Engineering Center-Hydrologic Modeling System (HEC-HMS) models have been assessed in simulating streamflows in the sub-humid tropical Kabini basin in Kerala, India, spanning 1260 km2. Calibration and validation utilized daily weather data from 1997 to 2015 from the Muthankera gauging station. The study investigated the impact of routing methods on runoff simulation in the ArcSWAT, exploring Muskingum and Variable Storage methods. Evaluation metrics encompassed Nash–Sutcliffe Efïciency (NSE), Coefficient of Determination (R2), Percent bias (PBIAS), RMSE-observations standard deviation ratio (RSR), and Peak Percent Threshold Statistics (PPTS) approach for high-flow values. The result indicates that HEC-HMS outperforms SWAT concerning R2 and NSE values during daily calibration and validation. Monthly simulations showed HEC-HMS closely aligning with SWAT (Variable storage), outperforming SWAT (Muskingum). The PPTS approach proved effective in simulating high-flow values. Both models exhibited proficiency in streamflow analysis within the study area, promising predictive potential for future hydrological studies in sub-humid regions.Keywords
This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit:
- Modeling, mapping and analysis of urban floods in India—a review on geospatial methodologiesEnvironmental Science and Pollution Research, 2021
- Identification of Suitable Hydrologic Response Unit Thresholds for Soil and Water Assessment Tool Streamflow ModellingChinese Geographical Science, 2021
- A review of SWAT applications, performance and future needs for simulation of hydro-climatic extremesAdvances in Water Resources, 2020
- Comparative evaluation of conceptual and physical rainfall–runoff modelsApplied Water Science, 2020
- SWAT Model calibration and uncertainty analysis for streamflow prediction of the Tons River Basin, India, using Sequential Uncertainty Fitting (SUFI-2) algorithmModeling Earth Systems and Environment, 2017
- ISFRAM 20152016
- SWATgrid: An interface for setting up SWAT in a grid-based discretization schemeComputers & Geosciences, 2012
- Sensitivity and identifiability of stream flow generation parameters of the SWAT modelHydrological Processes, 2010
- Adductor tenotomy: its role in the management of sports-related chronic groin painArchives of orthopaedic and trauma surgery, 2009
- Evaluation of HEC-HMS and WEPP for simulating watershed runoff using remote sensing and geographical information systemPaddy and Water Environment, 2009