Sound and faulty arguments generated by preservice biology teachers when testing hypotheses involving unobservable entities*
- 6 February 2002
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Research in Science Teaching
- Vol. 39 (3) , 237-252
Abstract
A sample of preservice biology teachers (biology majors) enrolled in a teaching methods course formulated and attempted to test six hypotheses to answer a causal question about why water rose in a jar inverted over a burning candle placed in a pan of water. The students submitted a lab report in which arguments and evidence for testing each hypothesis were presented in an if/then/therefore hypothetico‐predictive form. Analysis of written arguments revealed considerable success when students were able to manipulate observable hypothesized causes. However, when the hypothesized causes were unobservable, such that they could be only indirectly tested, performance dropped, as shown by use of three types of faulty arguments: (a) arguments that had missing or confused elements, (b) arguments whose predictions did not follow from hypotheses and planned tests, and (c) arguments that failed to consider alternative hypotheses. Science is an enterprise in which unobservable theoretical entities and processes (e.g., atoms, genes, osmosis, and photosynthesis) are often used to explain observable phenomena. Consequently, if it is assumed that effective teaching requires prior understanding, then it follows that these future teachers have yet to develop adequate hypothesis‐testing skills and sufficient awareness of the nature of science to teach science in the inquiry mode advocated by reform guidelines. © 2002 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Res Sci Teach 39: 237–252, 2002Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Teaching & Learning the Scientific MethodThe American Biology Teacher, 2001
- The Generality of Hypothetico-Deductive Reasoning: Making Scientific Thinking ExplicitThe American Biology Teacher, 2000
- Effects of Emphasizing Hypothetico-Predictive Reasoning within the Science Learning Cycle on High School Student's Process Skills and Conceptual Understandings in BiologyJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 1999
- A Scientific Approach to Teaching about Evolution & Special CreationThe American Biology Teacher, 1999
- What are the relative effects of reasoning ability and prior knowledge on biology achievement in expository and inquiry classes?Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 1998
- Accelerating the development of formal thinking in middle and high school students IV: Three years after a two‐year interventionJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 1993
- The Nature of Scientific Thinking as Reflected by the Work of Biologists & by Biology TextbooksThe American Biology Teacher, 1992
- Reasoning about logical propositions and success in scienceJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 1990
- The rejection of nonscientific beliefs about life: Effects of instruction and reasoning skillsJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 1990
- Teachers' perceptions of the effects of a scientific literary course on subsequent learning in biologyJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 1990