Cool Rationalities and Hot Air: A Rhetorical Approach to Understanding Debates on Renewable Energy
Authors:
- John BarryJBJohn Barry
- Geraint EllisGEGeraint Ellis
- Clive RobinsonCRClive Robinson
- 1 May 2008
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MIT Press in Global Environmental Politics
- Vol. 8 (2) , 67-98
Abstract
A key obstacle to the wide-scale development of renewable energy is that public acceptability of wind energy cannot be taken for granted when wind energy moves from abstract support to local implementation. Drawing on a case study of opposition to the siting of a proposed off-shore wind farm in Northern Ireland, we offer a rhetorical analysis of a series of representative documents drawn from government, media, pro- and anti-wind energy sources, which identifies and interprets a number of discourses of objection and support. The analysis indicates that the key issue in terms of the transition to a renewable energy economy has little to do with the technology itself. Understanding the different nuances of pro- and anti-wind energy discourses highlights the importance of thinking about new ways of looking at these conflicts. These include adopting a “conflict resolution” approach and “upstreaming” public involvement in the decision-making process and also the counter-productive strategy of assuming that objection is based on ignorance (which can be solved by information) or NIMBY thinking (which can be solved by moral arguments about overcoming “free riders”).Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- The effectiveness of different policy regimes for promoting wind power: Experiences from the statesEnergy Policy, 2006
- Invalid theory impedes our understanding: a critique on the persistence of the language of NIMBYTransactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 2006
- Crossing the Great Divide – Using Multi‐method Analysis to Understand Opposition to WindfarmsPublic Administration, 2006
- The evolving UK wind energy industry: critical policy and management aspects of the emerging research agendaEuropean Environment, 2006
- Policies and market factors driving wind power development in the United StatesEnergy Policy, 2005
- Globalisation, Ecological Modernisation and New LabourPolitical Studies, 2004
- Wind power, discourse coalitions and climate change: breaking the stalemate?European Environment, 2004
- Dutch wind power policyEnergy Policy, 1996
- Entanglement of Interests and Motives: Assumptions behind the NIMBY-theory on Facility SitingUrban Studies, 1994
- Conflict management and conflict resolutionTerrorism and Political Violence, 1990